clares that no one group of men, no matter how intelligent or influential, has the moral right to speak in the name of the Jewish people, until the Jewish people have delegated that right to it.
Acting on the presumption that the powers it had assumed and arrogated to itself constituted its charter of rights, the American Jewish Committee listened to the advice of. the New York Kehillah and called a meeting of its members, and decided that the best thing for the Jews to do in the face of the tremendous problem that now confronts them was to have the various national organizations meet in conference behind closed doors. But the question as to what are national organizations, and what shall be discussed and whether the conference should meet behind closed doors, and the powers of said conference, was decided by the same American Jewish Committee alone, without consultation with the various national organizations whom it had decided should be invited to this conference. Nor was the conference to be free to decide its program for itself. A resolution adopted by the American Jewish Committee on June 20th, at which practically only New York Jews were present, was to be binding on the conference. Furthermore, the conference was not to be a responsible meeting of Jews, whose resolutions were to be binding upon the organizations represented. This was to be merely a “conference” of Jewish organizations with the American Jewish Committee; the American Jewish Committee, seeking advice and suggestions. admitted the organizations into the conference to make recommendations to it, which it would later either carry out as suggested or lay on the table for future consideration.
In other words, th&e American Jewish Committee, through its limited and circumscribed conference, was to receive the endorsement of the various organizations, and the control of American Jewish affairs was to be left unaffected by the conference; in fact, its control would naturally be strengthened by the submission of all organizations to its pre-arranged program. In the resolution of June 20th to call the Conference, the words “sole object” were to be construed, and were deliberately inserted to prevent the conference from taking action on matters affecting the organization of American Jewry. This naive bit of political astuteness has passed by Jewish public opinion without comment except for the obiections of the Jewish Congress Organization Committee.
The whole question was thrown into the field of peace negotiations when Mr. Brandeis, representing not only the Zionists, but all organizations favoring the Congress, met Dr. Cyrus Adler, representing the small group of men who have hitherto spoken in the name of American Jewry with absolutely no moral or legal right thereto.
DR. ADLER'S BREACH OF NEGOTIATIONS.
What did Mr. Brandeis propose? We ask our readers to peruse the correspondence between him and Dr. Adler carefully, and not allow themselves to be confused by the specious attempt made to make it appear as if the Zionist federation has broken the negotiations by an overt act in favor of the holding of a Congress.
It is necessary to pause a moment here to point out the desperate and unfair state of mind in which the representative of the American Jewish Committee now finds himself. There is on record a pledge made by one of
the officers of the American Jewish Committee to the Congress proponents that, pending the negotiations between Dr. Adler and Mr. Brandeis, the American Jewish Committee would not issue any further invitations to the Washington Conference. It was understood that the Congress advocates also would take no step in the direction of calling a Congress until the negotiations were concluded. This did not preclude the continuance of the agitation for a Congress, nor did it preclude any propaganda by the American Jewish Committee for its conference. What it did preclude was any overt act in the direction of bringing into being either the Conference or the Congress. That is to say, nothing was to be done by either party to irrevocably commit it to Conference or Congress.
What happened was this: The Congress advocates contented themselves with making propaganda for the Congress. They presented arguments; they held meetings ; resolutions were adopted; but nothing actually was done to call a Congress into being. In spite of the agitation, the making of peace would have merged all this organized sentiment into either the Congress or the Conference or any compromise assembly that may have been called. On the other hand, pending the negotiations, the American Jewish Committee, through Dr. Adler himself, issued an invitation to the Conference to the United Synogague of which Dr. Adler is president, and at the annual convention of the United Synagogue forced the adoption of a resolution accepting the Conference invitation and electing its delegates thereto. This was an overt act, tending to commit the American Jewish Committee irrevocably to the limited Conference The breach of negotiations was further broadened by the sending out of practically all of the invitations to the Conference immediately with the mailing of Dr. Adler’s letter of August 3rd, in which he refused, on his own authority presumably, to call a general meeting of the American Jewish Committee to reconsider its resolution of June 20th, which was an essential step in the direction of peace if it was intended that some compromise Conference or Congress was to emerge out of the peace negotiations.
MR. BRANDEIS' PROPOSITION.
Now, what did Mr. Brandeis propose to Dr. Adler? He asked that seven or nine of the more influential national Jewish organizations meet for the sole purpose of selecting the twenty-four or thirty-six other national Jewish organizations who were to be asked to confer as to how and when and where the Congress or Conference or Assembly should be called. Mr. Brandeis further asked that these twenty-four or thirty-six organizations, each represented by one delegate, be free to decide any question involved in the calling of the Congress or Conference or Assembly; that it be bound by no resolution and by no program, except that it be understood, as a basic principle, that the Congress or Conference or Assembly must be organized on a democratic basis.
Dr. Adler's reply was a refusal to allow the delegates of the twenty-four or thirty-six organizations to decide for themselves the program of the Congress or Conference or Assembly; the time and place and method of representation; or whether there should take place a Congress on Conference or Assembly. He considered himself bound by the resolution of June 20th, adopted
