The Conference of the Provisional Executive Committee
Decides in favor of a Democratic Jewish Congress
The conference of the Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs was held on Sunday afternoon, June 27th, in the Old Boston City Club. Mr. Louis D. Brandeis opened the conference with a report on the general features of the work of the Committee. He was followed by Mr. E. W. Lewin-Epstein, the treasurer, who gave in detail the methods of distribution of the funds of the Committee in Palestine. His report will appear in the next issue. After Mr. Lewin-Epstein had reported, Mr. Brandeis added:
Brandeis: There are a few words I ought to say supplementing Mr. Lewin-Epstein’s report. This morning I stated that after our own great cause, it was the United States which has been next of importance in enabling us to assist our brethren in Palestine and to maintain there the Zionist Institution. Third in the list, immediately after the work of our own government, ought to be mentioned the extraordinary work of Dr. Arthur Ruppin. Nobody, save those who have occasion to consider in detail what Dr. Ruppin has done, can begin to realize the extraordinary ability and devotion with which he has managed our affairs. I have had in other walks of life occasion to meet men who were leaders in financial administrative affairs of work. I can say, without exaggeration, that in all my experience I have never found work which seemed uniformly of a higher or more trustworthy nature in any and every respect than that of Dr. Ruppin. Every Zionist in America and every Zionist everywhere may feel assured that every cent of money that goes to Palestine to be administered by Ruppin or under his direction, will be administered as effectively in every respect as it is possible, but aside from that great business ability which he has shown, he has shown statesmanship of the highest order. If there were need of presenting to the world proof that the Jews of Palestine possessed high statesmanship and the capacity to administer themselves, we have but to refer them to the work of Dr. Ruppin. It may seem almost like exaggeration for me to dwell so upon this matter, but I may tell you that never a letter comes from him which does not deepen my conviction that it is our great good fortune to have in Palestine at this time men of the great breadth of view and of the high character and judgment of Nr. Ruppin. BR
Dr. Harry Friedenwald moved the following resolution: That we express, through our Chairman, to the President of the United States and to the Secretaries of State and Navy our grateful appreciation of their cordial help in affording protection and relief to our brethren in Palestine, and that we thank the Government for the aid rendered by the Diplomatic and Consular service, and especially by the U.S. Ambassador to Turkey.
Carried. Mr. Perlstein read his report as Administrative Secretary. This report will be given in full next month.
Judge Aaron J. Levy: I come here with a committee of those representing Jewish Congress Organization Committee that has been laboring approximately four months for the all-important question of a Jewish Congress, during which period of time fourteen organizations have taken action by proper resolutions.
We appeal to you, Mr. Chairman, to take the lead in co-operating with us in this plan for a Jewish Congress and, briefly, and in a moment, I shall direct the attention of this conference to the wise and eloquent remarks of the chair made today and a year ago. The chair gave utterance to the thought that all Jewish questions are properly a consideration for the Zionists and that the struggles for human liberty and the removal of the disabilities and the security of equal justice are essentially within the province of Zionist undertaking. On the 23d of August of last year when a similar conference was convened the distinguished gentleman who occupies the chair today took occasion to say:
"I have found in them (speaking of the Jews of the America), the very qualities which we of the twentieth century long for in our aim for justice and democracy. Our claim is founded upon that very plan."
Continuing, he said: "It has made me feel that the Jewish people should be preserved, and it is our duty to go directly to the methodical saving of that people, which should be successful. We must work together and we need every one here and the tens of thousands which those here can influence."
In conclusion, I urge that these sentences are far more expressive in their emphasis of the position we represent in this body than anything [ can say. We demand that human liberty which the Jews have been denied; the removal of those disabilities from which they have so inhumanely suffered and the securing of equal justice, and I know of no way by which those things so human and so humane can ever be accomplished than by a full and free American Congress of Jews where the voice of all may be heard and where all classes and shades may be properly represented so that whatever command is issued may come forth authoritatively from the American Jewry as a whole and without a question on the part of any one whether he does or does not represent American Jewry. I ask your serious thought on this subject which so vitally affects the Jews this whole world oser.
Brandeis: I think it proper before there is any discussion of this proposal that I should lay before the delegates present the resolution of the Provisional Committee of May 9th; that in the opinion of the Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs it is desirable that at the proper time a Congress of American Jews, convening on a democratic basis, should be held for the consideration of the problems of the Jewish people.
Lipsky: It is my serious responsibility, in common with a number of the delegates here present, to ask your judicious consideration and adoption of the following resolution: (see page 18).
The resolution was seconded by Mr. deHaas.
Leon A. Kohn: May I inquire whether Mr. Lipsky is aware of the fact that the American Jewish Committee has decided to call a coneress or conference.
Lipsky: As every one knows, a private meeting of prominent gentlemen in New York, who have constituted themselves a committee, decided to call a limited conference to discuss a limited program. This small conference selected by various organizations, whose names have not been given, on a basis of representation which has not been made public, is to meet some time in November. It is to take up questions that may be considered by any group of Jews at any time and anywhere. Any group of men may confer solely for the purpose of considering the Jewish question as it affects our brethren in belligerent lands. What we here propose is something altogether different. Let the prominent gentlemen of New York hold their conference. That does not interfere with the holding of an American Jewish Congress on a democratic basis to consider the nationalistic problems of the Jewish people.
Judge Mack: I have been given to understand that the so-called private conference has been the subject matter of resolutions by the American Jewish Committee at the instance of the New York Kehillah and that a copy of those resolutions have been transmitted to this body with the reauest that it be laid beiore it.
Brandeis: It has come to my notice that a copy of that resolution has been sent to the Federation of American Zionists, but nothing to this body.
Mack: If Dr. Magnes, who is on that committee, and who is one of the four Zionists who form a majority of the committee of the American Jewish Committee, to whom has been
