THE MACCABAEAN
DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS
VOLUME XXVII
ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901
Published monthly for the Federation of American Zionists by The Maccabaean Magazine, 44 East 23rd Street, New York Entered at New York Post-office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00. All foreign countries including Canada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address
CONTENTS
EDITORIAL
WHAT IS THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE CONGRESS? THE Congress movement is the attempt of Jews to meet the responsibility of the great European catastrophe in such a way as to place that responsibility upon every Jew living in this free land. It is the attempt to bring about the articulation of Jewish opinion. Gradually, the bureaucratic methods of the American Jewish Committee have contracted the area of responsibility. More and more, the men claiming to be leaders have limited the circle of interest. In New York, this has resulted in the utter indifference of thousands of well-to-do Jews. The support of Jewish institutions, the responses to the call for relief by our suffering brethren in Europe, the general indifference of Jews, is due primarily to the assumption of power and responsibility by a small group of men. This small group of men does not supply the financial requirements of the situation. This small group of men uses the wealth and influence of one or two men to maintain their unwarranted control of Jewish affairs. As a result, the burden upon the one or two men becomes hcavier and heavier, and the interest of the large mass of Jews, and especially of the large middle class, becomes weaker and weaker.
At this time, when every lew, no matter how indifferent he may have been, feels his kinship with Jews, when even the radical socialistic trade-union Jews are stirred as they have never been before, when in every hamlet and town and city where there are Jews there is a keen interest in and sympathy for Jews in distress, it is nothing short of criminal for any small group of men to interpose their veto to a movement which is destined to place a permanent responsibility upon all the Jews of this countrv.
Has this small group of men in the American Jewish Committee met the great European catastrophe adequately? They have not. Have they responded adequately to the cry of the needy? They have not. The relief funds, inadequate as they are, were collected by the large mass which is now calling for a division of the power and the responsibility. Having failed in this great emergency, having demonstrated beyond the shadow of a doubt that they must have the support of all American Jewry, it is a flaunting of the spirit of democracy, or American ideals and of Jewish tradition, for them to obstruct the unity of Israel for the sake of a petty, partisan advantage over the rest of Israel. Efficient bureaucracy has its place in life, but an inefficient and unresponsive bureaucracy must be destroyed for the sake of the great task that now confronts us.
THE CONGRESS AND THE AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE.
THE issue between the Jewish Congress Organization Committee, representing fourteen national Jewish organizations at present, and the American Jewish Committee, is not clearly understood even by those who sympathize with the Congress movement. This confusion of thought is due to the inability of many Jews to think in terms of democracy when considering Jewish questions. The American Jewish Committee represents the obsolete type of Jewish representation, the assumption of responsibility and the consequence arrogation to itself of all privileges and powers. The Jewish Congress movement is a direct challenge to the assumption of responsibility and power by any self-constituted committee or organization. The Jewish Congress movement de-