consider the motion adopted for abolishing Flag Day.
A vote taken for a reconsideration of the question showed 7 for and 58 against.
The Chairman: I believe the motion is lost. There is not a two-thirds vote.
Mr. Samuel H. Borofsky of Boston: I believe it is a majority that decides and not a two-third vote.
Mr. E. J. Bromberg of Boston: The Commonwealth of Massachusetts requires a majority.
Mr. Bernard A. Rosenblatt of New York: In view of the fact that we are in Massachusetts, I move that we abide by its laws.
The Chairman: The sentiment for reconsidering the motion seems strong and since a majority vote is required, the motion is now before the house.
Resolution: That the First Day of Chanukah be, and the same is hereby designated, as the annual Flag Day.
Mr. Abram Goldberg of New York: The fact is that we have always waited for the masses to come to Zionism without making any attempt to go to them. That is why we have adopted a Flag Day and a Flower Day; it is a means for going to the people. These two days are more inspiring than those of you who do not know can quite imagine. To be stopped in the street and asked to buy a flower for the Jewish National Fund, and to be told what the Jewish National Fund is, is an inspiration. If you object to having children sell flowers, the same objection then holds good as to flowers. If the children are the objectionable feature then you can eliminate the children, but you need not do away with the day altogether. Two days in a year to come to the masses is not too many.
Mr. Charles Cowen of New York: I would like to ask that the floor be given to Miss Szold; though she has voted for a reconsideration of the motion, she is not convinced as to the value of the day. The children and young girls are sometimes approached in their work in a way that makes it very objectionable, and it is necessary that we should give serious consideration to this matter.
Miss Szold: I am not yet convinced that I was wrong, but I would rather that others who feel about it in this way should speak.
Mr. Leon Kohn of Newark: I believe the entire discussion is out of place. Those of us who voted against the resolution this morning did it out of our own understanding of the matter; our confidence is alike in Miss Szold and the officers of the National Fund Bureau. Personally I believe that if we concentrate our efflorts on Flower Day we can collect as much money on that one day as on both days. My own experience has been that many refused to work on one day because they knew they would be called upon again. From the standpoint of the public, they will not give twice as much because they are called upon twice; they remember that they have given once before. There is still another phase of it. It must be remembered that we are called upon to do a great deal of Zionist work in other directions; there is Dos Yiddishe Folk, The Maccabaean, the Emergency Fund, and it is getting to be confusing to us and to the public. The directors of the National Fund being intent upon their own work have lost the proper sense of proportion.
Why should our girls and children be called upon to do this work? These girls and children are open to insult and criticism of such a nature as to be unfit to be placed before this convention. For these reasons the majority of this mornine will again be the majority of this afternoon.
Mr. L. Bernstein of Springfield: I move that the debate be closed.
Mr. S. Abel of New York: I merely want to correct a statement made by Mr. Kohn who seems not to be familiar with the relations of the Federation and the Jewish National Fund Bureau. It is not a fact that the National Fund Bureau is unfamiliar with other Zionist activities than National Fund activities. The members of the National Fund board are three—one elected by the Federation, by the Mizrachi and by the Paole Zion, and the Chairman is a member of the Administrative Committee of the Federation.
The Chairman: We will now take a vote on whether or not Flag Day shall be continued as a practice by the Jewish National Fund Bureau. All in favor. (Response 67.) All
against the motion— (Response 74). The Chairman declared the motion lost.
The Chairman: Mr. Brodie will now place before the house a number of resolutions.
POALE ZION AND MIZRACHI.
Mr. Israel I. Brodie of Baltimore: Resolved: That the Federation of American Zionists suggest to the Provisional Committee for General Zionist Affairs that it request the Poale Zion Organization, Mizrachi, and other affiliated organizations, in arranging collections of any kind, to designate such days as will not conflict with the days previously designated by other Zionist organizations for similar collections.
Adopted. Resolved: That the Federation of American Zionists suggest to the Provisional Committee for General Zionist Affairs, that it request that the Poale Zion Organization to refrain, from collecting funds on Shabbos or any of the holidays, and also refrain as an organization from doing other acts which may be misconstrued as a desecration of Shabbos or any of the holidays.
Rabbi J. Jasin of Fort Worth: As a matter of fact there are other organizations that have been desecrating the Sabbath and instead of mentioning the Poale Zion, I would suggest that we say "all" organizations.
The Chairman: There are certain facts that seem to make it necessary to call this to the attention of the Poale Zion; it is not necessary with all other organizations.
Mr. Israel I. Wolf of New York: We sent a protest to the Poale Zion and they did not heed it.
Mr. Benjamin S. Gross of Birmingham: I move to close the debate.
Carried. The Chairman: The motion before the house will be re-read by Mr. Brodie.
Mr. Brodie re-read the motion. Mr. S. Abel of New York: In view of the fact that there is not sufficient data on which to form a fair judgment, I make a motion to table the resolution.
Lost. Motion as originally given, adopted. Dr. A. S. Wolf of the Knights of Zion: Called for the signatures on the Poale Zion resolution. He said: The Convention should not do such a thing. It reflects on all of Zionists to charge one of its organizations with disloyalty to its own cause.
Mr. Israel I. Brodie of Baltimore: Resolved: That the Federation of American Zionists withhold a charter from newly-organized societies in cities in which analogous local groups of Zionists already exist, or in which a Zionist Council is maintained, until such new society secure in writing the sanction of the previously analogous local groups, or of the Council.
Mr. Samuel H. Borofsky of Boston: I move that this be referred to the Executive Committee.
Adopted. Mr. Brodie: I present the following protest signed by a number of delegates, and ask that it go on record. The undersigned delegates to the Convention, having observed that the propaganda methods of the Mizrachi have resulted in the withdrawal of a number of societies affıliated with the Federation, hereby protest against the employment of these methods. They suggest to the Mizrachi that in the interest of effective co-operation between it and the Federation in the common cause, the Mizrachi should concentrate its efforts upon securing an acceptance of its principles by the very large body of orthodox Jews whom it is the chief aim of the Mizrachi to serve, and furthermore, that hereafter the Mizrachi should refuse to tak&, under its jurisdietion any society now or hereafter affıliated with the Federation without the eonsent of the Federation.
Ordered that petition go into the record without comment. Mr. Brodie: Resolved: That the Executive Committee of the Federation of American Zionists is authorized to maintain a press bureau, the duties of which shall be to furnish to the general press authoritative information concerning the Zionist movement.