The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 1 · July 1915
23printed page
scan 22 of 42

Rabbi Goldberg: The Teachers' Association does not ask for material support. There is much chaos now in the matter of Hebrew education and I think it is the duty of the Federation to support the Teachers' Association.

Mr. Saul H. Feingold: The Hebrew teachers should be more particular about religious observances.

Mr. M. I. Silverman of Worcester: There should not even be any question whether the Federation should give its support. The Federation should even establish a curriculum of education; the Shaari Zion of Worcester suggested that six months ago.

Mr. N. Persky of New York: In spite of all the criticism it must be admitted that Hebrew education is really the result of Zionist activity, and behind that is the Federation of American Zionists. I am ashamed to have to speak of the importance of Hebrew at the Zionist convention. The Federation need not take the whole thing over, but it should certainly give its moral support.

Din WM 3 ukiae-uh Yen en re Mrs. S. P. Burstein of Cleveland: This discussion is entirely superluous. How can Zionism be separated from Judaism and Judaism from Hebrew? If we neglect Hebrew we neglect the most important phase of Zionism. We should give our energy to the support of our culture. If we want a Jewish land, we must have Jews to bring there; if we neglect to train our children as Jews, whom will we bring to Palestine?

Mr. Jacob Landsberg of New York: Why should there be any controversy as to whether or not the Federation should give its moral support to Hebrew education? We ought not only to accept the resolution, but we ought to give it financial support as well; it is our duty.

Mr. M. W. Norwalk of New York: The question is not that of moral support; it is also a matter of organization. The fact is that the Talmud Torahs have on their Boards of Directors people who are entirely incompetent to manage the subject of Hebrew education and the consequence is that the children suffer for it. The idea is that there should be a Board in the Federation who should take care of thoroughly of the subiect of Hebrew education.

Mr. Schachne Stein of Dorchester: Zionism and Hebrew education must be combined. The Federation should be instructed by this convention to establish a regular education bureau.

Mr. L. Scharfstein of Boston: The men on the Boards of Talmud Torahs are good enough business men but they are not competent to carry on the activities of Jewish schools. There should be chosen from among the Federation men a committee to talk the matter over with the Teachers' Association. There should be a regular program for the Hebrew education of our children, and that program we wish should be Zionistic and Jewish.

Mr. Jacob Landsberg of New York: I move the acceptance of this resolution.

Resolution accepted.

The Chairman: Rabbi Goldberg will re-read the resolution on the Hebrew periodical.

Rabbi Louis I. Goldberg of Norfolk: (Re-read resolution as given before.) We recommend that the periodical be either a weekly or a monthly, and that it be issued in New York City. We also recommend that before deciding upon creating a new publication, we look into the feasibility of taking over the Hatoren which already exists.

Mr. Brodie: The Resolutions Committee has a substitute motion.

The Chairman: Mr. Brodie will read the substitute motion of the Resolutions Committee:

Mr. Brodie: Resolved: That the Executive Committee be authorized to arrange for the publication of a Hebrew monthly or weekly, as funds of the organization may permit, or to secure a controlling interest in an existing Hebrew periodical, now being published in New York.

The substitute motion was accepted by Rabbi Goldberg.

The Chairman: I will give the floor to Mr. Reuben Brainin to talk on this subject.

Mr. Reuben Brainin of Canada: Before you consider establishing a Hebrew publication or taking over the Hatoren, I want to say that there is going to be published very soon

a Hebrew periodical—The Haderech. For how long it will appear depends upon how successful it is; but I think the Federation ought to consider that all arrangements for its publication is complete and whether another publication is feasible at this time. The Haderech, I promise you, will be entirely Zionistic and Jewish.

Mr. N. Persky of New York: I do not see what bearing a Hebrew publication in Canada has upon the proposal to issue a Hebrew paper in New York.

Mr. Brodie re-read the motion before the house, which was carried.

Rabbi Louis I. Goldberg of Norfolk: I move that the Federation authorize the Executive Committee to give its moral support to the organs of the Hebrew teachers—the Hamorah and the Haaviv.

Adopted.

Mr. E. E. Lisitsky of Buffalo: I wish to announce that the Hebrew teachers that are here met yesterday and formed themselves into an organization which will affiliate itself with the Federation, and we intend to organize such branches all over the country.

Mr. Brodie: I move that the organization of such societies or central organizations be hereafter discontinued, and that this convention place itself on record as being against this decentralization. They should form themselves into constituent societies of the Federation of American Zionists with direct control by the Federation.

Mr. Lisitsky: We meant it to be such an organization.

Mr. Brodie: I withdraw my motion. The next resolution is on:

SHEKEL DAY.

Resolved: That Purim is hereby set aside as the annual shekel day.

Mr. J. Landsberg of New York: Purim is too late for shekel day; the shekel period, I think, should begin on Chanukah and end on Purim.

Mr. S. Abel of New York: This resolution is merely to get your opinion as to whether we ought to fix this particular day as shekel day; regular shekel work can be done all the year.

Mr. Henry Drimer of New York City: It is necessary to see that Flower Day, Flag Day and Shekel Day do not interfere with each other and Purim was chosen for shekel day with that end in view.

Resolution adopted.

FLOWER DAY.

Mr. Brodie: Resolved: That the Sunday immediately preceding Shevuoth is hereby designated as Flower Day.

Mr. Samuel M. Schmidt of Boston: Flowers at that time are very expensive, and I think the day ought to be changed.

Mr. I. H. Rubin of New York: We are planning to use artificial flowers next year and those cities where flowers are expensive at that time of the year can use the artificial ones we have in mind to secure.

Mrs. S. P. Burstein of Cleveland: I made this suggestion to the National Fund because I thought it would save waste.

Mr. Abraham Spicehandler of Brooklyn: Instead of Flower Day being the Sunday before Shevuoth, I would suggest that it should be the week after.

The Chairman: I believe that it is evident that this convention cannot agree upon this question; I would suggest that the matter be turned over to the Executive Committee to decide upon it in co-operation with the National Fund Bureau.

Adopted.

Mr. Brodie: Resolved that the first Sunday of Chanukah be, and the same is hereby designated, as the annual Flag Day.

en Miss Henrietta Szold of New York: I wish to bring close to the consideration of the convention the inadvisability of having two days set aside for the National Fund during the year. Our information is from all parts of the country that so far as the women are concerned it is practically impossible for them to do valuable work of practically the same character twice a year. If there were only one it would be he Zionist national holidav in America: it could be made a