of these nationalities; they also are entitled to free development as a people."
Miss Szold: If that is the intention of the resolution then I think it ought to be accepted, but with our position made much more emphatic.
Dr. Harry Friedenwald of Baltimore: To avoid misunderstanding and the possibility of misinterpretation, I suggest that the committee which will have the formation of the final resolution in charge, should find some mode of expression containing the idea that all of these nations on both sides have expressed the one central idea—the recognition of the rights of smaller nationalities.
Mr. A. Goldberg of New York: What concerns the spirit of the statement is all right; but there should be avoided any possibility of misunderstanding as to our neutral position. It should be made very clear that we are interested in an equal consideration of our right to national existence. Our right is historic because it is a world problem. We have given our men as soldiers to all the warring countries—it makes no difference to us who is’right or who is wrong. We have the right to speak to the whole world and to ask for our rights as a people all over the world, and ask for our own land. In the name of culture and humanity we have the riecht to make the demand.
Dr. Kallen re-read the passage referred to by Miss Szold, with some changes.
Miss Szold: It is my impression that the passage even with the slight change is not altogether wise. However, if the wiser heads of this assembly disagree with me, I am perfectly willing to accept the statement as it stands. I only wished to call it to your attention for your consideration. Permit me to say that so far as I am concerned, I do not believe that the allies are fighting in favor of the principle of smaller nationalities.
Dr. Kallen: There are statements by the Prime Minister of England made in the beginning of the war declaring for the principle of smaller nationalities; Russia did the same; France did the same. We have no official communications from these governments, but we may rely upon what appeared in the public press.
Mr. Charles Cowen of New York: May I add that Russia, in entering the war, declared her position as intervening on behalf of the nationality of Servia.
Miss Szold: If those are the facts, I have nothing further to say.
The next point of controversy was:
"Over one-half a million of them are wanderers over the face of the earth, driven from the seat of warfare to the bounds of the Pale."
Dr. D. De Sola Pool: In the sentence, "over one-half a million of them," I would suggest that the word "Pale" be ruled out and the words "north, south, east and west" be substituted.
We must adopt the statement unanimously or not at all. We can accept the statement—it merely makes our Jewish claim openly and fearlessiy: we have the right to our claim for recognition as a nationality. We cannot afford to allow ourselves to be considered a subsidiary part of the nations. Let us adopt the statement unanimously and place it before the Provisional Committee as the basis for the Congress and let us give the statement all the publicity that we can in the five continents of the world, and let the statement represent our unanimous opinion.
Dr. S. M. Melamed of New York: I object to the alteration of the word "Pale."
Joseph Zeff of New York: To repeat an insult expressed by someone else is partly an insult. We cannot in our resolution repeat an insult cast by the allies, calling the Teutons Imperialists, and repeat the insult made by the Teutons, calling the Russian policy Pan-Slavic—that means the swallowing of Austria: as Zionists we cannot indulge in even indirect insults, but on the other hand the pogroms and other iniquities on Jews in Russia have nothing to do with neutral- iv.
Mr. A. Goldberg of New York: I move that the Chairman be vested with power to appoint several others to examine together with Dr. Kallen the entire statement and make such changes as they consider necessary.
Mr. Goldberg’s motion was adopted.
The Chairman introduced Mrs. Ben Jehudah who spoke in Hebrew:
Mrs. Ben Jehudah delivered an address in Hebrew, speaking of the great work of Theodor Herzl, and reminding the convention that the session was being held on the day of Herzl's death. She also spoke of David Wolffsohn, and suggested as a fitting commemoration of the occasion that Louis D. Brandeis's name be inscribed in the Golden Book of the National Fund.
The session then adjourned.
On Monday night was held the Banquet of the Convention at Mechanics Hall, where over 1500 people were seated.
SECOND SESSION.
The meeting was held on Tuesday, June 29, at 10 A. M., at the Old City Club.
Mr. Lipsky, Chairman, opened the session:
I believe that all of you have enjoyed the proceedings up to now, especially the public demonstrations which have been held. Some of you are still living in the atmosphere of last night which was an effective demonstration of the power of the Zionist movement. But as you know, the Zionist movement is not only a movement but also an organization and an organization must work calmly and deliberately, without allowing itself to be confused by large public demonstra- tıons.
This session of the convention is practically the opening one, and we have a considerable amount of important business to transact. I hope that all the delegates who are here will keep themselves in the proper mood for dealing with these questions in the proper way, and not allow themselves to be carried away by impulses. It is the business of the delegates to attend strictly to the business proceedings and to contribute calm and deliberate judgment.
I wish to call the attention of the delegates to the absolute necessity of refraining from making statements to the public press. I say this because in a number of newspapers, statements have appeared which are not correct as an expression of the attitude of the convention. All those who were here yesterday morning know that we were unanimous on the Congress proposition, and that there was no disorder and no discourteous demonstration of the members with regard to the action that was maken.
I wish to present several messages of greetings; messages have been received from Federation of Roumanian Jews, New York; Ahawas Zion and Brandeis Society, Washington; Zion Club of Jersey City; Sholom Aleichem; G. W. Smith of Troy; Sons of Zion, Philadelphia; Jewish Students and Graduates of the State of Nebraska; Newport Zionist Society; Omaha Zion Council; Jacob Massel, New York; Kansas City Chapter of Hadassah; Youngstown Camp, Ahavas Zion Society, Washington; Young Generation of Zion, Brooklyn; Zionist Council of Cleveland; Hashachar, New York; Agudath Zion Gate; Bezalel Society, Chicago; Zionist Organizations of Allentown; Hebrew School, New London; Harlem Zionist Society, New York; Copenhagen Zionist office; Bnai Zion, Charlestown; Jewish Nationalist Club, Chicago; Kadimah Gate No. 9, Chicago; Young Judaeans of Utica; Young Judaea Literary and Athletic Society, of New London; Agudath Zion of San Francisco. Hachooza No. 2. of St. Louis.
RABBI WILLNER REPORTS FOR TEXAS.
I give the floor to Rabbi Willner, of Texas, to report on the state of Zionism in Texas.
Rabbi Willner devoted several minutes to a description of Zionist activities in Texas. "In the city of Terrell," he said, "there is a society with a membership of eight, the reason being that in Terrell there are eight Jewish adults." Rabbi Willner complained that the Federation does not send speakers to the state of Texas.
The Chairman: Madame Pevsner has been to Texas this winter. Mr. Fromenson was also there. The work of Madame Pevsner especially deserves special mention. Madame Pevsner succeeded in interesting a number of influential peo- nle there who had been entirelv indifferent to the movement: