The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 1 · July 1915
17printed page
scan 16 of 42
Facsimile · scan 16 of 42
Scan of p. 17
Text · transcribed from the scan

piness of the Jews, not only in America, but all over the world. I did not demand then that there be a fuller discussion of it; I entered only a plea for postponement, for calm deliberation, because the atmosphere was not then one of calmness. I did not vote upon the calling of a congress, originated by that body, because I wanted to be in a position today of not having opposed the action recommended by our Provisional Committee, in order to advocate upon this floor a policy of peace and of friendship. Unfortunately the communication which the Chairman just read was addressed, through the unfamiliarity on the part of the writer with parliamentary procedure, to this convention instead of to the Provisional Committee; nobody is to blame for that, and nobody is to blame for its misdirection since it was improperly addressed.

The Chairman: I did not mean to convey the impression that the communication was not addressed to the right organization. It was intended that this letter and resolutions should be presented to this convention. I made the reference merely to explain away the impression that the letter was purposely withheld from consideration by the Provisional Committee.

RESOLUTION ON JEWISH CONGRESS.

Dr. Solis-Cohen of Philadelphia: Among other things, Dr. Cohen said: "Let us work in harmony; we cannot afford to dissipate our energies by division; we must be united to stand for Jewish rights; there is no division as to what is wanted; the division is only on the method. We must stand before the world as a complete whole.

"In the light of the resolution of the American Jewish Committee which has just been read, and bearing in mind the action of the Provisional Committee to call a Congress independently, and bearing in mind the invitation extended by the American Jewish Committee, I place before you the following resolution:

"That the Provisional Committee and the proper officers of the Federation be requested to confer with the American Jewish Committee and other committees having in view the assemblage of an American Jewish Conference or Congress, for the purpose of arranging, if possible, for one such call and one such assemblage on a basis satisfactory to all."

The Chairman: It is my duty to report that the Provisional Committee Conference yesterday, attended by about 80 delegates representative of the various organizations comprising the Zionist organization of America, including representatives of the Independent Order Brith Sholom and the Independent Order Brith Abraham, adopted the following resolution by a vote of 65 to 11:

"The Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs, having on May 9, 1915, declared itself in favor of the convening of an American Jewish Congress on a democratic basis,

"This conference of the constituent organizations of the Provisional Committee approves that declaration of policy. In furtherance thereof, it urges the Provisional Committee to invite the co-operation of other national Jewish organizations in the United States to issue a joint call for an American Jewish Congress, which shall consider the proper steps to be taken to obtain full civil status for the Jews in all lands and the further development of a home land for the Jewish people in Palestine."

Mr. S. C. Lamport of New York: The letter from Dr. Cyrus Adler should have been read before the Provisional Committee took action and not after; I have been a Zionist for many years, but this is no time for division; people who are not Zionists have the right to be heard too. The resolution presented by Dr. Solis-Cohen should receive earnest consideration; we cannot ignore the invitation of the American Jewish Committee if we are to be true to the principles of Zionism.

Mr. de Haas of Boston: I am going to ask this as a personal privilege—that I be allowed to say a few words. There is a great demand for cool and calm deliberation of this most important question; the people coming with this demand should come calm and cool themselves. If we are urged to do something, we should be urged in a way and manner that will make it possible for us to respond in a like way. I move

that this resolution of Dr. Solis-Cohen’s be referred to the Provisional Committee for action and that we have no further debate about it. If there is a possibility of arriving at complete understanding and combined action, we should do nothing that will compromise the dignity of the Jewish people.

Mr. A. H. Fromenson of New York: I formally move that the communication of the American Jewish Committee inviting the Zionists to participate in a conference, and also the motion by Dr. Solis-Cohen asking the Federation to take proper action for a joint assemblage, be referred to the Provisional Committee.

The Chairman: Mr. Borofsky asks for the floor to discuss the original motion. I declare him to be out of order.

Carried, with Mr. Borofsky standing in protest.

REPORT OF JEWISH NATIONAL FUND BUREAU.

The Chairman: The report for the Jewish National Fund Bureau will now be presented to you by Mr. I. H. Rubin.

Mr. Rubin of New York: So as to give you an idea of the growth of The National Fund in America, I give you here the income of our Bureau for the last five years.

1910-11 $20,149.25 1911-12 22,252.43 1912-13 29,637.34 1913-14 37,139.30 1914-15 50,000.15

The first year of our Bureau we were afliliated with 158 cities, the second year with 199, the third with 264, the fourth year with 305 and the last year with 322 cities, where collections for the National Fund were made.

There are more than 300 cities of 50 Jewish families or more where collections were never made. To reach them should be our next step.

The Flag Day which was celebrated for the first time brought $7,587.00. The Flower Day which was celebrated the second time in America brought about $10,000.00 against $4,000.00 last year.

Aside from the point of view of income, these two days have proven of great propaganda value, which cannot be computed in terms of money because by these means our ideal is brought into the open in such a way as to make a profound impression, and particularly because thereby we draw into active Zionist service such elements as have never before been employed in direct Zionist work.

In the names of our Directors we extend to you, National Fund workers of this country, our thanks for the good work done last year and hope that with your help the income of next year will be doubled.

Mr. I. M. Rosenthal of Detroit: I move the acceptance of the report.

Mr. C. Cowen of New York: In addition to the acceptance of the report, I move that a vote of thanks be extended to the officers—Mr. Abel and the others—who have worked earnestly and unselfishly.

Mr. I. Maltin of New York: I mention Mr. Rubin as no less deserving of thanks.

Mr. Jacob Divinsky: Propaganda is made for the National Fund Bureau by the Poale Zion on the Sabbath and it should be stopped.

The Chairman: I desire to correct Mr. Divinsky. The money collected by the Poale Zion on the Sabbath was for the Arbeiter Fund and not the National Fund.

Mr. H. Eiser of New York: It is done under the Zionist flag and should be stopped none the less.

The Chairman: Is there anyone here to speak for the Poale Zion?

No response.

The Chairman: The motion before the house is to accept the report of the Jewish National Fund Bureau, with a vote of thanks to Mr. Abel and Mr. Rubin and other officers.

Mr. J. Landsberg of New York: I move that the Poale Zion be asked to refrain from violating the Sabbath under the Zionist flag.

The Chairman: There is a motion before the house.

Motion to accept the report and extend thanks to Mr.