The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 6 · June 1915
102printed page
scan 1 of 32
Facsimile · scan 1 of 32
Scan of p. 102
Text · transcribed from the scan

of a Congress. This is regrettable, especially as the action of the chairman served no rational purpose. As the vote showed, a reconsideration would have meant only a repetition of the same vote of lack of confidence the adoption of the original binding resolution engraved on the record.

It is expected that the special meeting of the American Jewish Committee will be held on June 20th, but how the leaders of the Committee will vote has not been indicated. But whatever happens at that meeting, this is certain: The action of the Kehillah in defeating the propositions of the American Jewish Committee has publicly and effectively demonstrated that it is not worthy of being the representative of Jewish interests at this time when so many important questions must be dealt with in a judicious, comprehensive and constructive manner.

THE GREAT DEVASTATION.

ONLY hints of what is happening behind the screen of Russian maneuvers, and Polish incitements, come to us from abroad. The letters that are being published in the Yiddish press are only a meagre recital of the woes of millions of our brethren in the war zone. With the Poles actively re-enforcing the brutality of the Russian army, with Germany considering Polish Jews as enemies, with the Russian government expelling thousands of families from provinces where martial operations are anticipated, the lot of the Jews must be terrible indeed.

The devastation beggars description. The tragedy of it all is that little or nothing can be done to bring relief. As one section is relieved, another is affected. As one city falls into the hands of Germany, another falls out of its hands. Galicia is harrowed. Courland is harried. Poland is a battlefield on which the armies of three nations trample down cities and provinces in order to better to get at their foes.

What can money relief do now, while the smoke of battle covers the field? What good deliberation and counsel and plans when to-morrow may find still another nationality fighting, and still another invasion, always with Jewish life as the football of events.

We are to face the greatest rehabilitation work the Jews ever had to tackle. When we consider this great task, which will press upon us most when war ceases, ought we not, as clear-sighted well-wishers of our people, think of how to make impossible the anomalous situation of the Jews which is the real root of all our troubles?

For what does the war reveal? It reveals the fact that Jews are everywhere regarded as aliens, even in England, where the feeling prevails that all Jews are Austrians or Germans. No matter how many Jewish lads give up their lives for their land, the prevailing thought is that Jews have no share in the future of the people of the land, that they are aliens.

Has not the time come to assert our national rights. Is it not time to put an end to this anomalous situation?

THE THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY PROVOKED.

WE least expected the Jewish Theological Seminary to become a forum for tirades against nationalism. It is true that the funds for the maintenance of the institution were gathered from sources unfriendly

to Zionism, but with Dr. Schechter as the head of the Seminary, and with a majority of the Faculty active or inactive Zionists, the tendency of the institution has been, all these years, in accord with Zionist wishes.

It is puzzling to understand why Dr. Schechter himself should have taken occasion, at this year's graduation exercise, to condemn Zionism; of course, in his usual emphatic manner. The Zionists have in circulation an interesting Zionist pamphlet written by Dr. Schechter. He has been a welcome and valuable delegate to many of our conventions, where his favorable opinions regarding Zionism were heard by large numbers of susceptible young Jews. Because of his known espousal of Zionism, and owing to the true Jewish piety inculcated by the Seminary, most of the graduate rabbis of the Seminary are ardent workers in the movement. Why, then, should Dr. Schechter now preach against nationalism, which has been from the start the basic principle of Zionism?

Dr. Schechter has been aroused by the cruelties of war, which he charges to excessive nationalism. Because of that excess of nationalism, he feels that nationalism itself is a gross perversion, and should be fought. But why does he not consider that nationalism has also produced good things? That nationality has given us fine literatures, fine art, that it has promoted self-abnegation on the part of the individual for the sake of the nationality, that it has given color and beauty to life? Just as the freedom of the individual may induce excess of individuality, so the freedom of nations may produce chauvinism and group-pugnacity and groupmadnesses. But who will preach against the freedom of the individual? Who will deny individual full rights because of the misuse made of these riehts?

And at this time, when the rights of good nations are being attacked by bad nations, and good nations are defending themselves against the onslaughts of bad ones, when the question of the rights of nationalities to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness is on the table of the world’s discussions, why should we Jews now forego national liberty because certain nations have been guilty of criminal action against others? Is this not the time for us to assert that we are a nation grounded in righteousness,. and that from our national life there shall come forth not carnage and aggression, but peace and righteousness? Is this not the time to assert our national determination to be true to the ideals?

We appeal to the Dr. Schechter of a quieter mood against the Dr. Schechter obsessed by the calamity of war.

THE BOSTON CONVENTION.

IT is a misnomer to call the gathering of Zionists in Boston the Zionist conventions. We are not holding several conventions. There is one convention to be held in Boston, the convention of the organized Zionists of America. One branch of the movement may hold special sessions to consider the problems arising out of its special work, but all these problems taken together are to be on the agenda of the central organization, whose sessions will be the clearing-house for all Zionist organization problems.

The reports submitted will show a tremendous propaganda, and remarkable results, considering that we Zionists have hitherto represented onlv a small eroun of