ligious apathy, of our self-contemptuous aversion to Jewish names and Jewish labels becomes an open scandal, a reflection on our sincerity and our manhood; it is the absurdity of holding aloof for the sake of religion and, at the same time, flouting that religion by our whole manner of life, it is this incurable contradiction, this self-convicted disingenuousness which must degrade us in our self-esteem.
Under these circumstances, give me the honest, outspoken unbeliever, give me professed agnostic, avowed scorner of Judaism, rather than confirmed indifference, frivolous facetiousness and all the other forms of irredeemable shallowness and constitutional sensuousness that are willing to parade under the cloak of nominal affiliation with Judaism. The man with convictions as
to religious truths, be these convictions ever so negative, can be reasoned with; incurable religious apathy, the ingrained materialism which has nothing but cheap wit to contribute to all serious discussion, these are hopeless and valueless for all purposes of constructive religion.
"Look not at the vessel, but at what is in it!" Faction, conviction, dogma, in religion as elsewhere, are the mere outward mould; sincerity is the life-giving wine which matures in due time. "Truth will answer her way;" it will make itself clear, with the help of discussion; there is no occasion for fearing to meet, on the common ground of our love for all that is Jewish, those of our brothers whose conditions and surroundings of life are making it hard for them to find their way back to Judaism.
Jewish Nationalism and the Torah
By EUGENE KOHN
ZIONISTS are prone to resent the attitude of those Jews who, while admitting the fact of Jewish nationalism and the legituracy of Jewish efforts to regain Palestine as our national center, nevertheless, refuse to affiliate with the movement because many of its leaders have cut loose from Jewish religious tradition. This resentment is justified, for the democratic organization of our movement would give ample scope to these critics to work for the triumph of their ideals within the ranks. But we must not permit our indignation at the unresponsiveness of this large religious element to prejudice us as to the questions at issue between them and our "non-Judaistic Hebraists," to use the terminology of the latter. Moreover, many organized Zionists themselves, the writer of this article included, see a serious menace to our movement in the negative attitude that so many of its leaders, as well as of its rank and file, take to Jewish religious tradition. Wherein lies the danger that they fear?
The aim of Zionism is twofold: It strives both to preserve the Jewish People from disappearing through actual physical assimilation by the peoples among whom they live, and it endeavors, moreover, to preserve the spiritual distinctiveness of our people from the influence of ideals and standards foreign and antagonistic to it. It is with reference to the latter aim that the ‘“Judaistic” Zionist feels that the Zionism of the mere “Hebraistic” nationalist defeats its own ends. For the very nationalism of these nationalists is itself the result of assimilation. The jew is ever sensitive to outside influences. In a cosmopolitan age he suddenly discovers that the nationalism which he had cherished through the centuries was a colossal mistake, or rather he suddenly professes to discover that he never had really cherished it at all, that the only bond between Jew and Jew was one of a common faith, a religious mission. And then this cosmopolitan age gives way to one of nationalism ; ancient faiths are discredited ; ancient ecclesiastical organizations are stripped of their former powers, the development of national cultures becomes the dominant ideal. Suddenly the Jew discovers +hat his faith which he had cherished throughout the
centuries was a colossal mistake, or rather he professes to discover that he had not really cherished it at all; that Judaism has no dogmas that the genius of the Jew is not religious, but merely ethical, that he has no mission other than to live his own national life, etc. Obviously, a conception of Jewish nationalism, in order to be true to the aims of the Zionist movement, must not be derived from the nationalism of the European nations and then applied to the Jews, but it must itself be derived from Jewish sources and its evaluation of Jewish national cultural possessions must be based on traditional standards.
It is this principle which the non-religious Zionisı fails to apply in that he discusses Jewish nationalism and Jewish culture without reference to traditional Jewish concepts. In order to make my point clear I shall take a single instance, one which is fundamental, however, and point out what a radically different scale of values some of our Zionists apply from that which has expressed the settled conviction of Israel at least from the time of Ezra to the present. This regards the position of the Torah in Jewish life.
The traditional view regards the Torah as a divine revelation. This doctrine has persisted in Judaism i.. spite of the rise and fall of various philosophic schools. It has been firmly believed by Jews and Jewries living under the most varied conditions and surrounded by the most divers influences. The changes of philosophical viewpoint have brought with them changes in the conception of the manner of revelations but never a denial of revelation itself of the belief that Israel came into possession of the T'orah because God intended it for Israel’s authoritative euidance.
And yet the conception of the Torah’s place in Jewish life has been rejected by a considerable number of Zionists for another which is not only contrary to the traditional view, but which is vastly inferior to it in philosophical depth and ethical significance. This alternative theory may be stated as follows: The Torah is a significant product of the genius of the Jewish People. As an important specimen of Jewish culture it is entitled to reverence. Öbservance of its precepts may,
