THE MACCABAEAN
DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS
ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901
VOLUME XXVI
Published monthly for the Federation of American Zionists by The Maccabaean Magazine, 44 East 23rd Street, New York Entered at New York Post-office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00. All foreign countries including Canada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address
CONTENTS
EDITORIAL
THE KEHILLAH AND THE CONGRESS. THE second convention of the New York Kehillah was one of the most interesting and significant Jewish gatherings ever held in the metropolis. As our readers recall, the first Kehillah convention held on April 18th voted to postpone the consideration of a resolution on the Congress for one month in order that, in the meantime, the American Jewish Committee might hold a meeting with other organizations to consider the question. Instead of making progress in this direction, however, the American Jewish Committee appointed a sub-committee, which met with a sub-committee of the Kehillah, and prepared a compromise resolution for the second Kehillah Convention held in May. This compromise resolution, although it was abortive of the demands of the Congress advocates, was acceptable to all parties, and Mr. Schiff made the motion to adopt it, which was carried without discussion, although the points of order and questions of information provided ample opportunity to disclose a decided reluctance to accept it. Nevertheless it was accepted. Then a motion was made that this resolution (expressing the desire of the Kehillah that there be a Congress, and referring it to a special meeting of the American Jewish Committee to consider the advisability of calling one), be binding on all Kehillah representatives on the American Jewish Committee. This provoked a storm of opposition. Advancing no convincing argument, but relying on the plea that men should not be instructed in matters involving “conscientious scruples,” the leaders of the American Jewish Committee met a decisive defeat. They were out-argued and out-voted, and the motion stood that they must abide by
instructions. The chairman of the Kehillah, who had up to that time fought for a Congress, and was regarded by all as being an uncompromising advocate of it, on his own motion moved to reconsider the binding resolution, and another debate was held, which again resulted in the defeat of the American Jewish Committee leaders. They were actually beaten morally as well as by a roll-call, for all their protestations lacked sincerity and plausability. They did not even pretend that they cared for public opinion. They rested upon their past achievements, upon their reputations, upon covert allusions to dangers, but at no. time spoke frankly and freely. They would not deign to take the convention into their confidence. The delegates present would have been unworthy of confidence had they permitted themselves to be beguiled into support of such an attitude.
The fact that the leaders of the American Jewish Committee were voted down twice decisively, notwithstanding the presence of Messrs. Marshall, Schiff and Sulzberger, indicates clearly that the day of the personal representative of Jewish interests has passed. No matter how much good may be done by such a representative, the ultimate good is questionable. The American Jewish Committee, in this encounter with direct representatives of the people, showed that it lacked the qualities of leadership under the newer circumstances, and that it could not lead nor was it willing to lead if the people had a voice in the matter.
Owing to the action of the chairman of the Kehillah in deliberately attempting to abort the action of the delegates, the Kehillah has lost a great deal of the confidence inspired by its recent determination to force the calling
