himself in a world very different from that in which his immediate ancestors have lived—a world full of the most varied claims and interests, and offering the widest possible field for the development of his powers, in whatever sphere he may choose to exercise them. This world is dominated by traditions which are not his traditions; its ideals differ in many ways from his; it has been influenced, perhaps, by the teaching of the ancient Hebrews. but it has developed for centuries along lines of its own, and it displays few signs of kinship with the Hebrew spirit. It is, or at least professes to be, complete, all-embracing, self-sufficing ; it has no need of the Jew who comes into it from his Ghetto. The need is on his side: he needs modern culture, the benefits of the modern command of nature, the opportunity of turning the wisdom of the moderns to material ends. Thus it is the world that gives, and the Jew that accepts with gratitude. Perforce he takes all that the world can give him; perforce he accommodates himself to the new atmosphere. But this is not to say that he gives up entirely his own individuality, or entirely loses what he has brought with him from the Ghetto. Bent on becoming really at home in the world, he is also determined to remain a Jew; in some way or other Judaism must be fitted into this alien life. Since, however, this life is complete in itself, with a full equipment of ideas, aspirations, institutions, inventions, and so forth—since, in a word, it needs nothing from Judaism, it follows that Judaism will not play an active part in it, or will only do so as the result of a conscious struggle on the part of the Jew to assert himself as a Jew, to force the world to take something from him in return for what it gives. In practice, for obvious reasons, this struggle is not carried on very widely or very long. The odds are too severe. The individuality of the Jew is first undermined by his enforced absorption into an alien culture, so that it becomes less and less clear to him that Judaism really means anything that the world does not mean; and then, even should he wish to fight for something so shadowy, the material difhculties are enormous. The Jew who sets out merely to preserve Judaism in a passive sort of way —merely to retain such of the traditional observances as are not wholly impossible under modern conditions, and to train up his children so that they will do likewise— even he has an almost impossible task, if only for economic reasons. To do more than this—to make Judaism an active force, bringing the world somewhat nearer to the Hebraic conception of what life should be—is an ideal to which even the strongest and the most gifted cannot hope to attain. But a merely passive existence cannot be indefinitely prolonged; and hence toleration means inevitably, though not immediately, the death of Judaism. Slowly but surely the distinctive Jewish type, and the distinctive Jewish outlook disappear ; Judaism, as a function of the Jew’s being, atrophies; and the end cannot be long delayed. The blessing of toleration disintegrates and kills Judaism, just as surely as the curse of anti-semitism eives it intensitv and vitality.
This, then, broadly stated, is the Jewish problem. Confine Judaism in the Ghetto, and it will remain strong and vigorous, but at the expense of being out of touch with life, and incapable of healthy development. Transplant Judaism to a free soil, and its vitality will be sapped,
its existence endangered. The modern world seems to offer the Jew nothing but these two alternatives, neither of which is satisfactory.
Pa re ne N de Se ne A To state the problem in this way is to indicate its solution. For if either attitude of the modern world towards the Jew is fraught with danger to Judaism, and if, therefore, we cannot regard universal toleration as a goal ultimately more satisfactory than universal anti-semitism— then it follows that we must find some third possibility ; and there is no alternative except that of an independent Jewish life, in which Judaism will be neither persecuted nor tolerated. It appears at first sight as though this solution must command the assent of all who see the problem; and in a sense this is true. For while many Jews in modern times have worked for the preservation of Judaism on other than Zionist lines, it may be doubted whether any of them has seen the problem as it appears to us to-day. Anti-semitism has always been regarded as the great enemy, and that not so much because of its effects on Judaism as because of its effects on individual Jews. It has been too hastily assumed that to replace conditions of anti-semitism by conditions of toleration throughout the world would be to solve the Jewish problem. But toleration, as we have seen, creates an even severer problem for Judaism; and if it is possible to fight anti-semitism by book and pamphlet, by inducing civilized nations to help persecuted Jews by diplomatic action, and so forth, the more subtle attacks of toleration are not to be met by any such simple means. And even when emancipated Jews realise that emancipation is dangerous to Judaism, they are naturally slow to believe that the danger lies in emancipation itself, and not in some accidental circumstancee. Hence they try to preserve Judaism by “reform,” by readjustment to modern conditions; they try to give the educated Jew an intellectual interest in his Judaism through the so-called “Jewish science.” It is only when these palliatives prove as ineffectual as the palliatives designed to meet anti-semitism that the real reason of their uselessness comes to be understood. To improve the lot of this or that Jew— whether the improvement take the form of better material conditions, or of a bridge across the gap between traditional Judaism and the modern world—is not to solve the Jewish problem. The number of individuals to be helped will always be greater than the number alreadv helned.
It is the distinctive feature of Zionism that it attempts to deal with the problem of the Jewish people and of Judaism, and not to solve the problem of this or that individual. You may alleviate the lot of the Russian Jew, or make the mental conflict of the English or American Jew less acute; but so long as the conditions remain as they are, there can be no end to the problem. You are fighting a monster whose heads grow as fast as you cut them off; and energy spent in a battle of that sort is energy wasted. That energy ought to be set free for the task of carrying on the development of the Jewish people; but it can never be so set free until we put an end to the conditions which make the present struggle necessary. We must cease merely to look at the individual. The problem is a national one, and demands a national solution. Save the nation —place it in a position where it can live out its own life, free alike from the cramped con-
