THE MACCABAEAN
DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS
ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901
VOLUME XXVI
Published monthly for the Federation of American Zionists by The Maccabaean Magazine, 44 East 23rd Street, New York Entered at New York Post-office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00. All foreign countries including Canada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address
CONTENTS
EDITORIAL
THE KEHILLAH CONVENTION THE annual convention of the Kehillah this year was prevented from being an ordinary routine convention by the wise decision of its leaders to open the proceedings to the airing of the question of an American Jewish Congress. All rules as to the affiliation of organizations were temporarily abrogated, and the aim was to get together delegates of various parties and groups, who would give expression to the sentiment of New York Jewry with regard to the holding of the Congress.
T'hat nothing came of this effort is not due to the neglect of the Kehillah leaders. Dr. Magnes in particular pressed the question with all the power at his command. But the reactionary forces in the Kehillah, represented by the leading officers of the American Jewish Conmittee, utilized to the utmost the power they derive from their position and wealth to deter action and to stifle the freedom of the Jews of this community. The reactionary temper of the American Jewish Committee was best indicated by the address of Louis Marshall, its president, in the debate. Mr. Marshall advanced "a number of specious arguments against the holding of a Congress. But he also threatened and scolded, concluding with the undemocratic and un-American declaration: “If you insist and persist in calling a Congress, T’II have none of it."
It is unfortunate that the word Congress is being used to express the desire of the Jewish population of this country that the Jews take action in an open man-
ner ın making a demand for their rights. "The program of such a Congress is already made. It is in the public mind. "There is no need for discussion. What is needed is such an expression of Jewish strength and purpose as will indicate to the world that the Jews regard their interests as being bound together, that they want national rights, equal rights and national rights, that they want Palestine open to Jewish migration, and that they want the Jews as such to be granted these rights. A Congress, in effect, is needed to give sanction to such a definite program. It means a registration of the Jewish will to be revarded as a national entitv.
Considering the Congress in this light, the opposition of Mr. Marshall and‘his friends lacks common sense, No neutrality is broken by the Jews demanding universal, equal and national rights. No neutrality is broken by the Jews asking for free access to Palestine. The sanction for such a demand rests in the fact that the Jews are a distinct and separate people, with interests that are peculiar to themselves. Why object to a Jewish committee appearing before the Peace Conference and presenting these demands? They will be refused a hearing! Put that would be an injustice toward the Jewish people. Why should we assume that the nations coming together after this bloody war will refuse to act justly by the Jewish people? Our cause loses nothing by any act of injustice on the part of others. We are not dealing with legal technicalities. We are concerned with elementary human rights. It is our dutv to proceed according to the dictates of our own