The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 4 · April 1915
59printed page
scan 2 of 24

In recent years, his fame has been slightly obscured. It was felt that his talent was unable to overcome the tumult of change that had come into Jewish life. He was no partisan. He held himself aloof from the polemics of the Ghetto. Occasionally, he spoke out on immediate questions, but always with such artistic reserve, that he himself, individually, seemed to be but slightly affected.

Of all Yiddish writers, he was the artist. While he wrote a great deal, he was careful, conscientious, true to himself, unwilling to thrust himself into the marketplace with his own griefs and woes, content to remain the observer, the student, and leaving to others the blare of publicity.

BE Far re Ir He started as a Hebrew writer, but under the influence of Jewish life, he turned to the masses, whom he loved, and wrote for them. "The masses probably never understood him, for his aim was high, but he brought into the new Yiddish literature a strain of high-mindedness and of lofty literary ambitions which had been lacking. Many writers looked up to him and together with them, the Jewish people mourn the loss of the most inspiring personality in their imaginative literature.

AN AUTOPSY WITHOUT A CORPSE.

THE Yiddish press has resounded with replies to Dr. Chayim Schitlowsky’s recondite observations on what he calls “The Third Churban.” He has been sharply criticized for relying upon reports coming from Alexandria, and his argument that because, as reported, Jews are leaving Palestine, Zionism was bankrupt, has been met with vigor by Dr. Levin. He has also been rebuked for making public a confidential interview with Dr. Herzl. Altogether, Dr. Schitlowsky does not emerge with flying colors.

EP DE een min Ama - Me It is not our intention to intrude into this discussion, for any philosophic utterances based on cable despatches, and written in a hurry, or with partisian bias, can have no value as permanent contributions either to philosophy orto sane journalism. What is reprehensible in Dr. Schitlowsky’s performance, and unworthy of a man of his standing, was his eagerness to pronounce the doom of Zionism. Assuming that the reports were true, that Zionism was bankrupt, decency required the postponement of the autopsy for a few days. At least, a friend of the Jewish people, appreciating the amount of self-sacrifice that had been thrown into the new settlement, appreciating what it meant to the Zionists to have all their hopes blasted, would have shed a tear, and mourned the loss of a fine activity on the part of the Jewish people.

But Dr. Schitlowsky was not following his instincts or his feelings. He was a cool-blooded and cold-hearted historian. He at once began philosophizing, tracing to their origins the causes of the downfall, and talking of the Churban as one might talk to-day of the suppression of the revolt of Bar Kochba. That a man could talk so coldly of so great a calamity, is a strong indictment of his competence as an observer of Jewish life, and a strong criticism of his genuine concern in the realites of Tewish life.

Fortunately, the reassuring news coming from Palestine makes it possible for us to take Dr. Schitlowsky's philosophy with a grain of salt. There is no need of an autopsy, for the corpse is alive and as active as ever.

THE PROBLEM OF IMMIGRATION.

THERE is a radical difference of opinion among sociological experts as to the problems of immigration that will arise in this country after the war.

Some restrictionists are of the opinion that with the coming of peace, a flood of immigrants may be expected to knock at the gates, and therefore some steps should be taken to forestal such a possibility. Prescott Hall declares that a large immigration is imminent and that notice should be given now to the world, stating that the United States declines henceforth to regard itself as the open-for-all melting pot, into which all nations may fling their undesired subjects.

A prominent Jewish organization adopts the same position, but does not, of course, endorse the restrictionist plea. It is prepared for the flood, or is preparing for it by appealing for a large fund to meet the inevitable emergency.

On the other hand, there is just as good authority for the belief that we need not be alarmed; that immigration will resume its normal movement after the war, but will not be anything out of the ordinary. These authorities say that the war will improve conditions in Europe for the survivors, for once having survived the war, no one will feel like leaving his native land just as better conditions are about to arrive.

All this is problematical. It is obvious, however, that the problem of the displaced, especially for the Jewish people, will become an acute one after peace is declared. Thousands of Jewish families will have lost their supporters. Thousand of Jewish families will have been reduced from affluence to extreme poverty. Whole communities of Jews will have been displaced and forced to move into other cities or countries. There will certainly be, for several years to come, crowds of widows and orphans and cripples, incapacitated men and women, who, not having a legal place of residence must seek a new home. It may be that the United States will not see many of these, but the Jewish people must confront the problem of an army of penniless and hopeless people, who will be forced to appeal to the philanthropic instincts of their own folks.

In addition, the communal wealth of many Jewish cities in Russia and Poland and Galicia will have been destroyed. They will not be in a position to take care of their own poor. They will lack hospitals, schools, orphan asylums, free loan societies—the paraphernalia of a communal life built up in the course of many generations. Some one will have to provide these needs. These needs may not knock at the gates of this country, but they will be Jewish needs, and the Jews of this country, co-operating with our brethren abroad, will be asked to deal with the problems arising out of them.

In other words, it is possible that there will not be a flood of Jewish immigration to this country, but there will certainly be a large demand for relief of Jews. How to settle these questions, and rehabilitate Jewish life how; possibly to prevent emigration, and to rehabilitate Jews where they feel at home; what to do with the homeless and helpless; these are Jewish national questions that cannot be settled by any one community. These questions demand the calling of a Jewish con-