The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 4 · April 1915
58printed page
scan 1 of 24
58
THE MACCABAEAN FOR APRIL.

curred, Dr. Paul Nathan was the agent for all Jews in the distribution of relief. Many hundreds of thousands of dollars were distributed by him through agents selected by him. It is proper to inquire whether this agent and this organization deserves the further confidence of the Jewish people.

At a time when all Jewry is concerned in the plight of our unfortunate brethren in Poland and Galicia: when millions of our brethren are suffering all the outrages of war, foot-balls of racial enmities, helpless victims of complicated hatreds on all frontiers, this German Jewish organization has had the audacity to assert that in a matter involving Jewish interests, Jews of Russia and the Zionist fund were to be regarded as enemies and not entitled to a voice in the disposition of their common property. The Hilfsverein was the invocator of a German legal war measure, not the German government. The Hilfsverein declined to postpone action until these other Jewish organizations could be represented. The Hilfsverein acted throughout with cold-blooded indifference to Jewish interests, and sought to make political capital out of Jewish distress. Such an organization, and such men, are not proper Jewish representatives, and they must be deposed.

We are not, as said, keenly interested in the formal aspects of the title to the Technicum. We raise a question here which is pertinent to immediate Jewish interests.

We understand that the American Jewish Relief Com- wittee has appointed the Hilfsverein, or James Simon and Paul Nathan, its agents for the distribution of relief funds raised in this country and apportioned to the Polish Jews. If this is so, it is the duty of the American Jewish Relief Committee to revoke its agency. It is immaterial how well the Hilfsverein may do this work—and on that point much can be said—but the continuance of an arrangement whereby the Hilfsverein, an utterly un-Jewish organization, represents the free Jews of the United States, acting as their intermediaries in works of philanthropy, cannot and should not be countenanced anv loneer.

After the war, the Hilfsverein's plunder-act will be taken up by those who are interested in the title to the Technicum; but it is the duty of every American Jew to demand that the American Jewish Relief Committee dissociate itself from an organization guilty of so scandalous an act as has been perpetrated by the Hilfsverein in the Technicum affair.

AN AMERICAN JEWISH CONGRESS.

ini 4 Ve re ee ee ee HE agitation for the calling of an American Jewish Congress continues, and while the objects of the Congress, and how it is to be called and by whom, are still vaguely sketched in the discussion, it is generally admitted that such a Congress is becoming inevitable. It cannot be stayed. It may be not a Congress, but a conference; it may not be wholly representative democratically speaking, but it will be part- Iy representative; its objects may not be clearly formulated, but there is a program to which all the parties favorable to the idea mav give their annroval.

If a Congress is to be called, it should not be the result of a heated discussion in the press. Such discussions do not enlighten and in most cases lead to badly-digested resolutions, and the entire process is affected by the spirit of compromise which comes as a result of partisan

wrangling. The preliminaries must be disposed of in private conference. The method of organization must be formulated not in mass-meeting or newspaper symposium, but in the calm deliberation of responsible men. The Congress proper should be free and unafraid, but the organization of the Congress is impossible unless all the problems of organization are first disposed of wisely and calmly by men who are able to view the situation from all sides.

Many have asked, Who shall call this Congress? as if that were the important question. Not who shall call it, but how it shall is to be called, upon what basis, with what intentions, —that is the issue.

It does not matter who gets the credit, but it does matter how the work is to be done and by whom. Is it to be done with a view to re-emphasizing the non-nationalist aspects of Jewish life, or is the Congress to speak for the national interests of the Jewish people?

In order that these questions may be decided judiciously it is better to delay the formal calling of the Congress until an agreement is reached between representatives of various shades of Jewish opinion. Nothing is to be gained by premature action. The Congress must be a genuine convocation of American Jewish forces;.it must be democratic and it must be national. If this can be attained, a few months’ delay is immaterial.

JUDAH LABUSH PEREZ.

YIDDISH literature is so constantly in a state of flux, that it is difficult to place any of its leading figures. Conditions change, the language itself is subject to such a variety of influences, and there are few if any standards. At times, one wonders whether the writer of to-day, boasting of an army of interested readers, will stand the test of a dispassionate and objective criticism; whether what we admire to-day will be tame and banal to-morrow. It is so young a literature, and the people involved are so old.

It has been said of Perez, who died this month, that he had experimented with all forms and had fairly mastered them all. He was a poet, a dramatist, a sketchwriter. He had imitated the symbolists, the decadents. The French writers, the Russian. In every field he wrote something that stands out with clearness, revealing an inquiring mind, a susceptible spirit, a fine imagination. His luck was that he was so saturated with knowledge of Jewish life, its lore, its poetry, its mystic qualities, its dialectics; for with this equipment, he reduced all forms to the peculiar needs of the life he saw. Probably because of this compelling Jewish impulse, many of the things he wrote in alien forms were imperfect and unsatisfying.

In one direction, however, he shone brilliantly. He knew the Chassidic life, its soul and its idiosyncracies. For in that life the Jewish imagination was free. In the unseen world, in the world of the spirit, beneath the rough exterior, there was liberty of fancy and imagination. In fantastic pictures and thoughts, in the whimsical combinations of reality and miracle,—in these Perez revealed himself as no other Jewish writer has revealed himself. An artist peculiarly sensitive to sounds, he wrote the music of Jewish life, sometimes wierd, sometimes uncannily true, and sometimes poignantly tragic. He was a lyricist. That was why his better work issued as the sketch, the picture, the monologue.