The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 3 · March 1915
49printed page
scan 15 of 25

has written a letter which has been given wide publicity, appearing with assurance even in the New Republic. In this letter, this ardent Pole questions the authenticity of reports coming from Poland, but his entire argument is based on the assumption that all these reports are true, and he seeks to justify Polish aggression against the Jews.

In Free Poland of December 18th, Frank S. Barc elucidates a theory of Polish opposition to the Jews. Mr. Barc justifies the boycott, which does not imply hatred of the Jews, but "means only that the Poles, who have allowed other elements to monopolize every thing are beginning to assert themselves. With them it means a self-defense carried on with honorable methods not against the Jews, but against their own gradual annihilation. "The Jews are foreigners. They are usurers and dishonest dealers, and they are a menace to the integrity of Polish nationality. They have the business and trade of the country in their hands; the banks and financial institutions are theirs."

This is the old cry of anti-Semitism, and need not be discussed in a Zionist journal. But the Poles must have something more in their minds than the denunciation of three million human beings living in their midst. They must, if they are statesmen and worthy of being entrusted with their own national destinies, have given some consideration to the national problem involved in a policy of extermination.

What is to become of the three million Polish Jews? Will the friends of free Poland leave the matter in the air and consider the problem solved by merely justifying hatred and opposition? Is it not clear that three million people cannot be theorized out of existence, and that their continued presence in Poland is bound to create a complicated and harassing problem, which will not be downed until it is settled on a basis of justice and humanity?

Can three million Jews be exterminated? Certainly they cannot, no matter what their virtues or vices may be, no matter what relation they may bear to Polish nationality. The problem becomes of the utmost importance not only to the Jews, but also to the Poles.

The solution of this problem cannot be left for future discussion and settlement. The Poles are looking forward to their national autonomy. Before they can be entitled to receive it, it is their bounden duty to offer a statesmenlike egress out of the dilemma. If they regard the Jews as a menace, they must propose a plan which will take into consideration the fact that the three million human beings they wish to eject also represent a common interest, and that provisions must be made for their future. They must formulate their ideas with regard to minority nationalities. Are all nationalities in Poland to be extirpated, or only the Jewish nationality? Are minority nationalities to have no rights? Is the Polish culture to be predominant, and all other cultures to be persecuted ?

The re-establishment of a free Poland involves the exercise of sagacity and statesmanship on th part of the Poles. Before they are given the reins, it should be known where they are driving to.

THE PALESTINE RELIEF SHIP

The U. S. collier "Vulcan" left on Saturday March 13th, from Philadelphia for Jaffa, with 900 tons of food. On board as representative of American Jews was Louis H. Levine of Baltimore, charged with the duty of distributing the food under the auspices of the United States consuls, to Jews, Moslems and Christians. Dr. S. Levin-Epstein represents the Provisional Zionist Committee.

This is a historic incident. For the first time in Jewish history American Jewry has taken up direct contact with Jewish life in Palestine. Hitherto, America has been the rich uncle, coming to the relief of Palestine, but unable to exercise the functions of a parent in the destinies of Palestine Jewry. Even in matters Zionistic, American Zionists have had little or nothing to do with the management of Palestine institutions supported by them, and certainly have had no hand in the policies of Palestinian settlement except as exercised through the Congress.

With the outbreak of the. war, however, all this has changed. American Jews, Zionists and non-Zionists, have instinctively understood that a heavy responsibility rested upon them. They have responded nobly, not only with money, but with common sense participation in the work of reconstruction. The money sent to Palestine has been distributed on a Zionistic basis, that is, not wholly from the charitable or philanthropic point of view. The interests of reconstruction have been held in mind. The sending of oranges here, with the hope of finding an American market for a staple product excluded by reason of war from other markets, was a step in that direction, and the projected financing of the orange-growers, to enable them to proceed with their work for the next ‘crop, is in line with a constructive policy.

The Zionists have instituted free loans, work for the unemployed, and only as a last resource, has simple unadulterated charity been given. From now on, America is an equal partner in the supervision of regenerated Palestine.

The sending of the "Vulcan" is also significant as an indication of the friendliness of the American government. The American government, with rare courtesy and humanity, has acted throughout with an understanding of the situation. It has served the Jewish interest with whole-hearted sympathy. As a result, Palestine will witness, on March 30th, for the first time a power of the first class acting as the intermediary for Jews in a work that is unmistakably Jewish. The thanks of American Jewry are due to President Wilson and Secretary Bryan for their broadminded Americanism, and their appreciation of the larger responsibilities of a democratic government.