The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 2 · February 1915
26printed page
scan 12 of 22
Facsimile · scan 12 of 22
Scan of p. 26
Text · transcribed from the scan

the knocker; if anyone dares to find any fault with things as they are, why—"Chuck him into the river,—he is an enemy to our town!" Presumably the kind of optimism our prophets cultivated was treated to very much the same dampening recommendation. I was present, one evening, when at the meeting of the economics society an optimist of the blatant kind was proposing the above cold water treatment for those who refused to join in the hurrah, whereupon a shrewd old Scotchman reminded him that, "if you want to swim, you must kick."

It would, of course, be useless to explain to those whose minds are wedded to surface reasoning that, just as real courage is not blind to danger, so the genuine optimism refuses to minimize existing evils, but is confident as to the triumph of justice in the end. Ask the anti-Zionist whether he is optimistic as to the Jew’s obtaining justice at the hands of civilized nations, his own home as a safe place of refuge; ask him about our capacity for self-government, our prospects for putting forth, on our own soil, under the auspices of free self-unfoldment, a full-grown culture of our own; ask him as to the prospects of Palestine for becoming again a land flowing with milk and honey, the world’s great experiment station for the bringing about of justice and brotherhood;— our optimistic friend will shrug his shoulders in pity over the extravagance of our visionary illusions. Not he is the visionary when he flatters people who will not send their children to Sunday School, by extolling them as religious missionaries destined to convert an unbelieving world; not his is an absurd optimism, when he expects the Sabbathless Jew, utterly indifferent to Jewish history and Jewish literature, ignorant of the Bible, weaned from the habit of prayer, prejudiced against Jewish observance and Jewish ceremonial, split up into factions which even the most appalling of emergencies cannot cure of their petty rivalries, when he expects this dispersed and disintegrated army, under these conditions of moral and spiritual diaspora, to conquer, as missionaries, the religious world; no, it is we, with propositions of building up a nation from the bottom, of rooting it in a congenial soil, of winning back for its distracted spirit its predestined and everlasting home, it is we who are the impracticable visionaries. Of course, what is more characteristic of the pessimist than enthusiasm? Who is ever readier for self-sacrifice than the black-seeing hypochondriac? What other man to arouse the poor and down-trodden to devoted following? It requires, according to this philosophy, a whole inky lava-tide of utterly discouraged melancholy to kindle the flame of inspiration which has called together world-congress after world-congress from all the ends of the earth.

There are times when those who are aware of my constitutional aversion to wire-pulling and diplomacy take it upon themselves to warn me that Zionism is a political clique, that in the Zionist ranks there are demagogues and politicians who are in the game for what they can obtain for themselves, that there are factions and intrigues and so forth. There is a measure of excuse for the anti-Zionist at a distance who may be honestly deceived into such undiscriminating condemnation. He has never witnessed the real spirit of a large Zionist gathering; he is not aware of the phenomenal capacity for heroic self-abnegation of which the convinced Zionist is capable; from the mere suspicion, from an individual dislike, he leaps at his conclusion. None but the frenzied partisan will ever maintain that all those are insincere who cannot see eye to eye with himself, but that a large proportion of anti-Zionists and non-Zionists, at least of those among them who have some inkling of Zionism, are the merest elbowers and time-servers, men who find Zionism in the way of their own schemes, careers, fawnings, I have not the faintest doubt. While Zionism is so far from fashionable, especially in the circles of the prosperous, as to be hardly respectable, it cannot appeal to more than a stray speculative spirit here and there. But ask the young lawyer

who has a career to mould with the help of the possessing classes, ask him to look into the truth of Zionist claims, to examine in the merits of Zionist ideals; you will find him unable to command the time for reading up on the subject; he prefers not to commit himself, knowing that, were he to embrace Zionism, some of his clients would begin to doubt the perfection of his mental balance. Your young physician, architect, business-man will evince a strange shyness, a timid reluctance, as you approach the subject; they have a reputation for good, hard sense to maintain which might suffer almost as much, were they to be known as Zionists, as if they had ventured to identify themselves with socialism or the single tax. Even among the rabbis you will find many a timorous soul that espouses the hazardous equipoise of a seat on the fence, going no farther than a cautious profession of limited sympathy, because one must not expose himself, either to the factional reprisals of enraged anti-Zionist in the front-ranks of one's profession or even to the pin-prick sneers of a facetious member or two.

There are honest fanatics among the anti-Zionist who still believe that Zionism constitutes a kind of high treason against our patriotic duty towards the countries in which we were born. All the Joseph Chamberlains, John Hays and other eminent statesmen of every modern nationality could not convince these men that such a thing is possible as faithfully serving one’s birthland, and, at the same time, ardently yearning for the land of one's fathers; no doubt, the conspicuous patriotism of Zionists in all the warring countries will not prevent their frenzied opponents, once the war is over, from again denouncing their Zionist brothers to the gentile world as traitorous ingrates. A Ludwig Geiger and his likes will continue to regard themselves as divinely appointed watchmen on the towers of sacred Germanism to sound the alarm against the high-treason of the Zionist, who aspires to any other future but what he can obtain from the scant mercies of a military “younkerdom” linked with rigid bureaucracy. Patriotism, of course, is something more than the favorite “refuge of cowards;” but there an intolerance bred especially by the thin-skinned, hysterical patriotism of the purblind assimilationist, which scents disloyalty and a breach of allegiance in every independent stirring that might possibly draw the fire of criticism. As the good son becomes the loving husband, so it is the loyal Jew who is most grateful and appreciative for whatever genuine brotherliness has been shown him by his foster-brothers in the land of his birth; when the Jew scarcely dared to dream of the attainment of full civic rights, he often rushed bravely in defense of his stepfatherland just as, even today, the maltreated and outraged Russian Jew is conspicuous by his patriotic conduct towards his undeserving native country. A betroyal of bloodbrotherhood, the denunciation, to an unfair enemy, of one’s own brothers on a mere quarrel of political opinion is a traitorous act infinitely more degraded and contemptible, just because, while pointing out its kin to the arm of the law. it is incurring no legal punishment.

There is levelled against the Zionist, finally, the severest of all charges, that of being untrue to Judaism. He dares to affiliate with the Jewish free-thinker and the Jewish atheist, he receives unto himself the Jewish nihilist; he permits the sacred tongue to be employed for other than religious uses, until, at times, it is made a vehicle even for the unsavory literature of the modern decadent. Because he tolerates such company he is accused of being indifferent to the cause of Judaism or even hostile to it.

Zionism is not the only movement which, originating outside of the religious aegis, started out with something like an anti-religious momentum. The Order B'nai B'rith, for instance, for many years, asserted its independence from religious mentorship by banishing from lodge-room and platform whatever seemed to have direct bearing upon

(Continued on Page 32)