The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 1 · January 1915
16printed page
scan 20 of 20

THE PROBLEM OF PATRIOTISM.

By HARRY SACHER (Continued from Page 2)

the State "does not only consist of a large number of inhabitants, but they must be of different sorts; for were they all alike there could be no State." Our imaginary critic of Zionism is really an echo of Plato, and the Zionist must reply with an echo of Aristotle.

We can think of the relation between the citizen and the State in two different ways. We can think of the State as of an army with a supreme purpose of its own, independent of the wills of those who compose it; while the citizens serve in the ranks under the subjection of a discipline which requires absolute devotion. From this point of view the State is everything, the citizen nothing except the servant of the State. On the other hand, we can think of the State as merely an organization which enables the citizen to live the highest kind of life, while the citizen is in the State because only through the State he is able to live the highest kind of life. These two political doctrines stand at the opposite poles, and while most men accept neither the one nor the other in its full rigour, all men incline either to the one or the other. The Zionist says that the British State exists for the living of the good life by the citizen, and that if Zionism helps him to live the good life it enables him to fulfill his duties as a citizen and to enrich the British State with the truest kind of wealth, spiritual variety and strength. There is a certain minimum of obligations which must be performed by all citizens—the payment of taxes, the duty in certain eventualities of defense, some participation in punlic affairs. Beyond this there is a large margin in which the citizen may select freely; and it is the use which he makes of this liberty of selection that determines the spirit in which he performs the indispensable minimum. One may be interested in art, another in science, another in history, another in sociology. This man may be a liberal, that a conservative, that a socialist. The roads to good citizenship are many and diverse, and the variety and multiplicity are large enough to include the way of Zionism. The Zionist can and does perform the indispensable minimum of obligation imposed by his British citizenship. His Zionism is concerned with that large margin beyond the minimum, and it is a dedication which enables him to per"form that minimum in a spirit which is of value to the British State. Zionism is an ideal, and the pursuit of an ideal is a first-rate school of citizenship. It is a nationalist ideal, and it shapes the mind for the understanding not only of Jewish nationalism, but of nationalism in general. The secret of all good citizenship is the recognition of the necessity to the individual of some larger whole. That is the secret imparted by Zionism, which purifies and strengthens individualism through the social spirit. The key to modern government is the true understanding of nationalism. That key is provided by Zionism, which preserves the citizen from the dangerous attractions of Caxsarism. Thus the Zionist is enabled to grapple with the problems of the British State as worthily as the best of its citizens, His eyes may travel beyond the seas, but they carry back observations of immeasurable value in the performance of the duties imposed upon him here. If it still be urged that the identification of the Zionist with this country is not complete enough, let those who make the retort consider how far their doctrine is likely to carry them. From Plato to the Inquisition, to the Act of Uniformity, to the Test Act, the step is short and direct. The position of the Jew is not identical with that of the Catholic or the Nonconformist; but what formula of political uniformity can be devised which will exclude the Jew and yet embrace the Catholic and the Nonconformist, or again allow for the infinite variety of Liberal and Conservative, Socialist and Anarchist, Imperialist and Little Englander? What good citizens do in this diffieult and tangled field is to correct and tame theoretical speculation by concrete experience. They avoid in the practical work of government carrying theoretical lines to infinity, for there are few if any lines which do not lead there, and few if any men who could not by such a process be thrust out of the community. “A State cannot be one in the manner which some persons propose, and what has been said to be the greatest good which it could enjoy is absolutely its destruction, which cannot be: for the good of anything is that which preserves it.” What Aristotle wrote 2,000 vears ar is as true to-day.

There is, in conclusion, perhaps one other anti-Zionist argu-

ment which deserves brief notice. It has been said that Jews in this country received emancipation on the implied or expressed undertaking of abandoning their Jewish nationalism, and that Jews in England to-day are bound by that undertaking so long as they retain the full rights of citizenship. One may take long to doubt whether emancipation was granted on the strength of any such undertaking, and still more emphatically whether Englishmen to-day regard us as holding it on such terms. If it is true that the Jewish advocates of emancipation used such an argument, it is also true that many a good cause is fought for and won by very mixed and dubious argument. To attempt to tie this nonsense of the Jewish advocates of emancipation as a yoke round the necks of Jews for all time is something too grotesque in logic—especially when it is remembered that not more than a handful of Jews now living in England are descended from those who won emancipation. We may say with Rousseau, "Even if each person could alienate himself he could not alienate his children; they are born free men; their liberty belongs to them, and no one has a right to dispose of it except themselves." To the Jew who ventures to tell us that fifty years ago our birthright was surrendered our answer can be brief and strong. No Gentile ventures it.

FEDERATION INFORMATION TO ZIONIST SOCIETIES

Br A a ee The Federation has prepared coin-cards to be used for mailing purposes by anyone desiring to mail his or her shekel. Twenty-five cents can be inserted in the card, which is to be placed in an envelope and mailed to the Federation office, which will send a shekel-receipt to the remitter. We are prepared to send any number of these cards to societies to be used by them in securing shekel-payers at meetings, or the coin-cards may be distributed from house to house with envelopes for their return to the Federation. Societies are urged to apply for these coin-cards at once. They can be made very useful in shekel proparanda.

Societies that have not ordered their shekel books are asked to do so at once. We must not neglect the shekel. Our organization depends upon the shekel, which maintains our central organization. Individuals should get shekel-books from their societies and sell them among those of their friends who sympathize with Zionism. Every Zionist should be a shekel-payer.

We call your attention to the fact that we have on hand copies of Dr. Richard Gottheil's book on "Zionism" which we sell for seventy-five cents. Every Zionist should have a copy of this book. It can also be used to advantage among non-Zionists. We urge every Zionist to purchase a copy of the Zionist Pocket Reference, which we sell for six cents. This Reference booklet gives statistical information about Zionism, the Zionist organization, Palestine, etc., which every Zionist should know.

The National Fund Bureau has decided to have a "Flag Day" for the National Fund on Purim, February, 28th. Make your preparations at once. Appoint your committees. The National Fund Bureau will communicate with you, giving all details.

Mr, S. Pevsner, of Haifa, Palestine, is in this country on private business relating to Palestine. He is interested in the extension of the Hoachozo movement, and the immediate purchase of land in Palestine. He will visit a number of cities, accompanied by Mr. S. Frankel, who is well-known to our comrades. We hope you will give Mr. Pevsner your assistance in reaching people in your city who may be interested in Palestine. Mr. Frankel will address meetings whenever they may be arranged in a city which he and Mr. Pevsner will visit, There ir no cost attached to Mr. Frankel’s services in this respect.