THE JEWISH INTEREST IN THE WAR
THE MACCABÆAN publishes the appended article without committing itself, or the Zionist organization, to the views therein expressed. The article was written with a view to clarifying somewhat the situation that has arisen, as a result of the conflict of sympathies that has arisen in the Jewish World. It aims to draw a distinction between the interests of individual Jews and Jews as a whole. While the MACCABÆAN restrains itself from a discussion of the point made, we hope that it will provoke a discussion among our readers.
NATIONAL self-interest decides the various sympathies aroused by the war. Self-interest made England the enemy of France, and then made it the friend of France. Self-interest made Japan Russia's enemy, and now the same sort of interest makes them friends. Italy became the ally of Germany and France when its self-interest was affected, and now self-interest restrains it from aiding its erstwhile friends in their struggle against many foes. Treaties are made for mutual protection, or for aggrandizements that are mutually profitable. Not common ideals—Russia and Japan have no ideals in common, nor have England and Russia—but common interests make allies, and no nation is expected to act contrary to what it considers its highest interests.
ce tt a Fan I Self-interests may, however, be regarded in two ways. ft may be of a defensive character. My self-interest demands that I protect my life, my property, my individuality. It may be of an aggressive character. It may be egotism that demands the appropriation of the property of another, the suppression of his individuality, or the destruction of his life. I assume I am dealing with the defensive self-interest, which is declared to be the interest of England, Belgium, France, Germany, Austria and Servia in this war.
Wholly different standards are invoked when the Jews are mentioned. We are regarded as free lances, possessed of no group or national interests, and therefore free to have nothing to do with our national interest. Our interests are localized, divided into fragments.
Soon after the war was declared, it was sought to cajole the Jews and bring them over to this or that side of the controversy. One would have presumed that with Jews fighting in all armies, no belligerent would have any reason to be dissatisfied with the Jews. There are said to be over 350,000 Jews in the Russian army. There are over ten thousand Jews in the British army. Jews are fighting for Germany and Austria with an ardor that has amazed the world. But all these manifestations of patriotism do not seem to satisfy. Because it is felt that we have no national interest, no one is pleased with the distribution of our sympathies.
er Br dr le a en A ar Fa a Especially is this dissatisfaction prominent in English circles, in the English press. England is disappointed with the Jews of America because they seem to sympathize with the Germans. They feel offended with the utterance of one of the leading American Jewish philanthropists of German origin, who has found occassion to criticise also England in his general condemnation of the forces that brought on the war. They regard the expression of sympathy with the Germans on the part of the Yiddish press as beine ungrateful. z
But is this fair?
Wherever Jews express an opinion regarding the war, they speak from the point of view of their individual sympathies or their individual bringing-up. A Jew born and educated in Germany, despite the fact that anti Semitism in that country may have affected his life, is also swept off his feet by the war mania, and he feels that his sympathies should go out to Germany. The same is true of an Austrian Jew.
ne a en En a ni 2 Eee Aa ai har ma a et 4 The fact is, aside from the expression of individual opinion, which has not been so frequent as England imagines, the Jews are in the best sense of the word the only neutrals in the United States. They maintain that neutrality as Jews, for when it comes to speaking of a Jewish interest, they have only one point to make. They are wholeheartedly neutral, except in one instance.
Is it to be expected that Jews hailing from Russia, who have known what Russian persecution means, should be sympathetic to an extension of power for Russia? Is it to be expected that Russian Jews, knowing what the Russian government has done to them, should be indifferent to the fate of their 2,000,000 brethren living in Galicia, who, if Russia is victorious, also become the victims of its tyranny?
They admire England for its liberality to oppressed peoples. England has been generous in its treatment of the Jews, giving them economic and political freedom. They remember that England is the land where a Beaconsfield developed and became its Prime Minister. They remember that George Eliot was an Englishwoman. They recall the chivalrous friendship of the Englishman, Laurence Oilphant. They remember with gratitude the offer of the late Joseph Chamberlain of a territory to be settled by Jews, an offer twice made. They know that England's culture has been vitally affected by its love and veneration for the Hebrew Scripture.
But they know Russia also. Whatever qualities the Russians may have, no one will venture to say that the Russian government have been even mildly fair to the Jews. They have been the rutiıless persecutors of the Jews in Russia. Is it not natural then for Jews who have escaped from the Pale of Settlement and found a haven of refuge in the United States to be lacking in sympathy, to say the least, when that country goes to war? Is it not natural that, so far as extending the power of that Empire, and allowing it to add a few more million Jews to its jurisdiction, that Jews should be unqualifiediy, in their sympathies at least, opposed to a Russian victory?
The opposition to Russia is not opposition to England. They are opposed to one of England’s allies. If England has entered into a treaty with Russia calling for co-operation against common enemies, acting throughout from national motives, is it fair to ask Jews to sympathize with such a compact or with the complications arising out of it, when their own national interests are affected thereby? Hundreds of liberty-loving Englishmen have protested against this alliance, and are now swallowing their chagrin at having to fight for the interests of their nationality, and at the same time aid in extending the power of a nation that has defied the ideals of England. The Jews in England also condone this offense. They are sacrificing their lives for England, knowing that when England wins, Russia also wins. But that is their dilemma. No such embarrassment of patriotic instincts troubles Jews living outside of the British Empire. They feel that in every other respect neutral, in this one instance, at least, their national interests may have free scope, and they are therefore opposed to Russia’s extension while it remains an oppressor nation.
It may have been otherwise had England used its influence to secure for Jews the natural rights of human beings in Russia. But England before the outbreak of the war consistently refused to exercise its influence on behalf of Jews. Since the war, various rumors are current as to what the English Prime Minister may be willing to do to right Jewish wrongs in Russia, But nothing now has been done, and it seems, nothing will be done.
And would it not be folly for Jews in this country to profess friendship for the Allies—with their malevolent partner— in view of what the world knows to be the Jewish interest? Even Russia will not be deceived. Every consideration of national dignity demands that the Jews refuse to countenance an extension of Russian power. Our interests are against such an extension, and no amount of words to the contrary can carry weight. Russia is consulting what it considers its own interests in its treatment of the Jews. Who will deny to the Tews the right to consult their own national interest ?
As Jews, therefore, we are absolutely neutral in this war, but our national interest demands that at least Russia’s influence shall not be extended. If in expressing such a view, Jews individually—high or. low in station—wish for the defeat of Russia, the fact that England is adversely affected by such an expression of our hope, is accidental. The Jews are certainly not responsible for the consequences. It is tragic. But then the war itself is a terrihble travedv.
