Our Own Neutrality
It is not so simple for the Jews of America to keep mum with regard to what they conceive to be Jewish interests in the war. As Zionists, of course, we are, in the best sense of the word, neutrals with no special interest affected by the success or failure of either side. But as an American Jew, it is natural for Mr. Jacob H. Schiff to speak with feeling of his suspicion that Germany is not being fairly treated. It is also understandable why the Yiddish newspapers have come out so strongly against Russia. Had the war been limited to Germany and Russia, our neutrality would have been thrown to the winds, for who wishes to see Russian reaction further extended; who would like to see Russia acquire Galicia with its large Jewish population? It would not have mattered that Germany has, as has been said, given anti-Semitism the benefit of its organizing skill, and formulated a philosophy of anti-Semitism and formal prejudice against Jews. Between the two no one would have questioned from which side Jews would derive the most benefit. Unfortunately, France and England are involved, and now Turkey is also involved, so that, from every point of view, it is probably better for us to refrain from weighing our sympathies and moving with the turn of the balance. It was singularly inappropriate for Dr. Richard Gottheil, who is offcially connected with the Zionist organization, being an advisory member of the Provisional Committee, to speak so freely of his sympathies, entering into an expression of friendship for Russia, at a time when we Zionists are bound in honor, for the sake of our comrades in Germany, if for no other reason, to remain silent. Certainly Dr. Gottheil will not find his views shared by the majority of the Provisional ('ommittee, and he has no right to giv: punlic utterance to his views at this time, unless he has had an understanding with the Provisional Committer, whi"h, we have ground for saying, has ncver been given to him. Dr. Gottheil should have been more keenly sensible of his responsibility as a Zionist.
The Atrocities in Poland
Georg Brandes, a friend of the Polish people, has written an indignant article, which appeared in Der Tor, protesting against the inhuman treatment of the Polish Jews by the Poles in Galicia and Russia. He gives accurate descriptions of how the Poles betrayed Jews to the Russians when their armies arrived in Poland, and then, in the same manner, betrayed other Jews to the Germans, when their armies drove the Russians out of Polish territory. Incidentally, in the confusion of siege and conquest, the Poles engaged in pogroms on their own account. What are we to expect when Poland attains its independence? The boycott is effective. Pogroms are now not a novelty. Is Poland to be classed with Russia, or will it take its place with civilized nations? The Poles are now appealing to America for sympathy. They are collecting a large relief fund. American newspapers, always susceptible to the claims of a people struggling for liberty, have already responded with enthusiastic editorials that dwell upon the indomitable courage and determination of the people who gave a Kosciusko to the world. But what will these newspapers write when they hear of pogroms and boycotts? Aside from the cruelty of illtreating Jews, do not the Poles understand that the surest way to alienate the sympathies of the world is to continue their boycotts and pogroms?
Distribution in Palestine
Mr. Maurice Wertheim has returned from Palestine and has given to the public a report of how he distributed the first $50,000 in Palestine. This sum was sent by the American Jewish Committee, Mr. Jacob H. Schiff and the Provisional Committee. The distribution is in the hands of Dr. Arthur Ruppin, Aaron Aronsohn and Ephraim Cohen, who co-operate with local committees. How Mr. Cohen came to be a member of the distributing committee is not clearly disclosed, and it is probable that some alteration will be made in the personnel of the committee to minimize the influence of a man who is so much out of sympathy with modern ideas in Palestine. Mr. Wertheim
