historian of Zionism and of contemporary Judaism.
What, for example, could be of more interest than a pamphlet written by D. Weizmann, some ten years ago, dealing with the possibilities of founding a Jewish university?
Again what could be more important than the written word concerning that unique society inspired by Achad Ha'am himself, and known as the Bene Moshe?
That Achad Ha'am has them, one can't help but believe, when one notices with what care he collects and reads all writings pertaining to problems in which he is interested.
We got more than a suggestion of this characteristic when Mr. Ginzberg turned to one of the party who was an ex-editor of "The Zionist," and said to him in a quaint way which he adopts on occasions in conversation, "You are 'The Zionist,' and I want to quarrel with you." "What, not 'The Zionist'? Well, your spirit is still there." Dr. Mendes had an article in the last number, in which he contended that the Zionist Movement did not have a sufficiently orthodox Jewish tendency. That article deserved an editorial reply, and your spirit is responsible for its not appearing there."
A lady intervened. "Yes, Mr. Ginzburg, I have seen an answer. I have received my copy only this morning, but if you say a reply has appeared, I will look in my copy." He went to a cupboard, found the missed article and, turning to the ex-editor, said: "All right, I will let your spirit rest in peace."
Every article in the nature of a criticism, and every book in the nature of an attack, however innocuous it might seem to the unwary, had to receive its proper answer. Nothing that endangered Jewish life or Zionism could be allowed to pass without challenge and counter-attack. It is this fact that has gained for him the reputation of being the foremost Jewish critic.
His whole life, his whole public work, has been a fight against the status quo
of the Jews. This necessitated a continuous activity which heightened and grew keener at special times of distress, renewed oppressions, massacres or "bilbulim." But more characteristic has been his fight with Jews themselves.
Salomon Reinach, a learned scholar, a member of the Académie Française, innocently writes an article in a little-known paper "L' Univers Israélite," in which he affirms that Eastern Jewry is suffering from an "inner slavery"—it observes the Sabbath and dietary laws. This "New Saviour," therefore, naturally suggests the introduction of "modern rational criticism." To Reinach the proposal was probably mild, somewhat unusual, of course, but since assimilation is advisable, and fortunately inevitable, why, it is nothing to be concerned about.
What did poor Reinarch say when he heard of Achad Ha’am and read in answer to him and his friends: ‘‘Slaves that you are, emancipate yourselves Arst!”
At the time of this call Achad Ha'am was engaged in writing an article in answer to Mr. Claude Montefiore's "Synoptic Gospels," and again the sharp incisive tones of the combatant are heard.
"But every true Jew, be he 'orthodox' or 'liberal,' feels deep down in his being that there is something in the spirit of our people—though we know not what it is—that kept it from the high road taken by other nations, and impelled it to build up Judaism on those foundations, for the sake of which the people remain to this day confined 'in a corner' with its religion, being incapable of renouncing them. Let them who still have this feeling remain within the fold; let them who have lost it go elsewhere. There is no room here for compromise."
It was late before the party broke up and wished Mr. Ginzberg a "good shabos." One went away with the feeling that it was a privilege to serve in the organization with which Achad Ha'am is associated.