The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 5 · November 1914
181printed page
scan 33 of 56

ple" is quite an American institution, and the Jewish flavor which still clings to it, whether more or less pronounced, does not prevent those who attend it from regarding themselves as fully assimilated.

But with the Russo-Jewish immigrants—and their numbers are now so preponderating that one has almost to look on them as the Jews of America par excellence—the case is different. A large number of these have brought with them neither the capacity nor the desire to "be melted." On the one hand they are hampered by their language, with which they can scrape along well enough if they add to it a perfunctory acquaintance with English for business purposes. On the other hand, as a result of their early education and training, they are still haunted, as it were, by some remnants of a conception of life in which "dollar chasing" has no part, and of a religion in which the God-idea is not that of a lukewarm and universalist Theism, but of an intense and nationalist monotheism. They bring with them an idealistic conception of life, and so long as they retain their language and their orthodox synagogue they never part with this entirely, whatever concessions they may have to make to American materialism. Although their bodies are in America, their minds are more on less still in "der Heim"; they come to the brink of the melting pot, but do not tumble in.

The real problem arises with the children of these men; and, as was pointed out in the "Times" some time ago, it is a problem of the utmost gravity, not only for the Jews themselves, but for the whole American people. This rising generation has capacities both for good and for evil probably transcending those of any other section of the American people. On the one hand, it must be admitted that the young American Jew shows a dangerous facility for imbibing one-half of the teaching of American life—the "dollar chasing" idea—while remaining quite impervious to its corrective ethical principle of theism. On the other hand, he has in the traditions of his race, and to some

slight extent in the example of his parents and grandparents, the incentive to something higher than America at its best can show him—to an idealistic outlook on life, and to a religion that shall be not merely an ethical, but an intellectual influence as well. It is in the hand of the Jew either to lower or to raise the tone of American life in general—to develop and emphasize either its material or its spiritual side. And it is to be expected that the rising generation of American Jews, of Russo-Jewish parentage, will do one or both of these things; it will not merely be fused into the amalgam, like the generation of German or English stock which preceded it.

For good or for evil, then, the rising generation of Jews in America is not likely to prove so amenable to the alchemy of the "melting pot" as Mr. Zangwill seems to think. Their resistance will be for evil if, so to speak, they become merely melted without being fused; that is, if they lose their distinguishing Jewish characteristics, and receive in exchange only the lower, the nationalist half of American civilization, without the ethical idea which serves as its counterpart and corrective. It will be for good if (to continue the metaphor) they become fused without being melted; that is, if they acquire all the externals of Americans while retaining the idealistic outlook on life which is the heritage of their people. Hoc opus, hic labor est. That a large number, perhaps the majority, will follow the first of these courses, it is hardly possible to doubt. It is, therefore, necessary, in order to redress the balance, that a select few, the "remnant of Israel," should make the toilsome ascent which leads to the spiritual, if not to the physical, Zion.

Jewish legend relates that the Holy Land was promised to Abraham only after he had passed through the flery furnace and come out unscathed. It may be that the Promised Land is once more destined for that part of the seed of Abraham which shall pass through the "melting pot" of modern America and not be melted.