The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 5 · November 1914
173printed page
scan 25 of 56
Facsimile · scan 25 of 56
Scan of p. 173
Text · transcribed from the scan

alistic patriotism, just as Roman Catholic is fighting against Roman Catholic, despite the claimed catholicity of Rome's spiritual power.

The reason for this breakdown of internationalism is simple. In each of us, both as individuals and as nations, there are two main tendencies in perpetual conflict— the heterogeneous and the homogeneous, or the particularistic and the general. In each of us there coexist the protestant desire for individuality and the catholic desire. We are jealousiy anxious to live our lives according to our own light, while at the same time moving in harmony with the conventions of society and grouping ourselves homogeneously with our neighbors. These two desires are clearly irreconcilable except through endless, elastice compromises. The socialist tries to ride through life astraddle two hobby horses on different paths in the effort to be a convinced Frenchman or German, keenly proud of his national individuality, while at the same time referring himself to the larger group of international organized labor. Similarly, the Roman Catholic has to be an ardent, nationalist patriot, while professing allegiance to a Church which recognizes no national boundaries. In like manner, the Jew juggles in acrobatic compromise to be the patriot of patriots in every land, while all the time professing a universal brotherhood with his fellow Jews.

Yet when we examine these conditions a little more closely we see that there is involved in them no real contradietion or practical difficulty. We have the most varied relativity in our group references. We are all of us at all times members of a large number of diverse groups. As a point may be conceived of as contained within an infinite number of possible circles, so any one human being is at any one time a member of a very large number of smaller or larger human circles. At one time he conceives of himself as a member of one circle, at another time he acts as a member of another. The writer of this can claim to be an American, an Englishman and a Jew, just as Mr. Jacob H. Schiff rightiy claims to he an American. a German and a Jew.

When the lot was cast to discover the man who had transgressed at the capture of Jericho, the people were taken first by tribes, then by families, then by households, until finally the individual was reached. Similarly every one of us may classify himself by tribes, families or households, in narrowing circles. Each of us may regard himself as a member of humanity, or, with narrower reference, of white-skinned humanity; or, still more narrowly, of civilized, white-skinned humanity; or of that sub-section of civilized, white-skinned humanity known as the Jewish people; historic branch of that race Ashkenazic, Sephardic, Russian, etc., local branch, American; specific local branch, of New York; more narrowly defined, of uptown New York, etc., within ever narrowing circles of classification.

The one who denounces the narrowness of patriotism as contrasted with internationalism regards each of these progressively narrowing classifications as betokening increasing prejudice and lack of breadth of outlook. Yet each classification is true and necessary in its place and context. The error of the anti-patriotic internationalist lies in trying to project all these classifications on the one plane. A child's drawing of a landscape will picture the sun, a house, a distant mountain and a nearby cow all on the same plane. But give the young artist the elements of perspective and some understanding of the third dimension, and he will place his house, his cow, his mountain and his sun in happy concinnity.

In this way, again following the suggestion of H. G. Wells, we must solve the vexed and acrimonious question of the relationship of Zionist patriotism to internationalism. Only a superficial generalization can brand nationalism as narrow in contrast with internationalism. Internationalism itself is narrow in contrast with a broad humanitarianism, as nationalism or patriotism is broad in contrast with city loyalty or family loyalty. Each is good and fitting in its own plane. The nationalist Jew need not fear the criticism which ex-acerbates the contrast between nationalism or patriotism and universal brother-