his home than the songs of his youth and home. National airs sung by exiles stir the sentiment of patriotism emotionally and profoundly. Zionism, in creating universal and truly national Jewish songs, is deepening and emotionalizing the sentiment of patriotism among the Jewish people, a nation of exiles.
Little need be said about land as a factor in patriotism. Patriotism, in a precise sense, is a term with purely geographical implication. The word patriotism means love of fatherland. There can, therefore, be no patriotism, properly so-called, without a fatherland. One may be loyal to a race, a tradition, an ideal or an institution. But when the race, the tradition, the ideal, the institutions are conjoined with a land, this loyalty is intensified into patriotism by local definition.
Zionism, by putting Palestine into the forefront of Jewish thought and work, has elevated Jewish loyalty into Jewish patriotism. The preceding Galuth generations cherished a magnificent loyalty to the Jewish people, Jewish institutions, the Jewish tradition, Jewish ideals, and a sentimental loyalty to Zion. Modern Zionism has given to this vague, homeless loyalty a local habitation and a name. Jewish autonomous colonization on a large scale in Angola, Cyrenaica, Brazil or elsewhere outside of Palestine would give the Jewish people a Jewish land and possibly even Jewish institutions. But, at best, such a venture would be only territorialism or "landism." The Zionistic development of Palestine is giving to the Jewish people Jewish traditions, Jewish institutions and Jewish ideals, all rooted in the Jewish fatherland. In a word, Zionism is giving to the Jewish people not only territorialism or "landism," it is giving back to Judaism and the Jewish people the sentiment of patriotism or "fatherlandism" in the fullest and finest sense of the word.
One consideration arises out of this relationship of patriotism to a native land which we may not pass over silently. Patriotism, as we have seen, is essentially bound up with a fatherland. But there is a strongly marked tend-
ency in modern thought to depreciate patriotism by contrasting it unfavorably with what, it is claimed, is the larger and nobler ideal of world patriotism. This cosmopolitanism first found definite expression in the writings of Comte. Comte looked forward to a broad synthesis which should transcend lesser patriotisms in a Positivist republic of educated, Western, white men, bound together by common culture, common interests and the Religion of Humanity. In this he consciously followed the analogy of an ancient, international institution, the Church of Rome, which has always claimed to be Catholic or universal. Early Christianity, looking forward to the proximate end of the mundane order, discounted all local patriotisms. “We recognize one commonwealth, the world,” said Tertullian. “We know that we have a fatherland founded by the word of God,” said Origen. Even in pre-Christian times, Anaxagoras, whose social and political views were perhaps no more pleasing to the Athenians than were his astronomical teachings, when asked which was his country, pointed to the skies.
But, as H. G. Wells has pointed out, the history of the Roman Catholic Church clearly indicates to us the inevitable fate of any international movement or catholic institution. That Church, while theoretically one and unitary, has in all centuries multiplied fissiparously into numberless sects, orders, rules, heresies, institutions and local branches. Every other attempt at internationalism must succumb to the same fate. Until a few months ago, we were told that all working men were brothers, and that states such as Germany, Italy, Belgium or France, in which socialism is strong, could no longer enter into a great war with one another. We were assured that labor would refuse to shoot against labor in the cause of any narrow nationalism or petty patriotism, now that the broadly humanitarian light of internationalism had dawned. But the tragedy of these recent days has shown us international organized labor unquestioningly and to a man deserting the remote, diffused light of internationalism to follow the closer and more intense light of nation-