The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 5 · November 1914
163printed page
scan 15 of 56
THE MACCABÆAN
163

liament and so forth could easily lead the holder of such position to abuse his power. Everywhere the functionary relied and had to rely on one class in order to govern and oppress the other. Marius relies on the plebs against the proprietary class and Sulla uses the later to subdue the masses. Always we find numbers opposing numbers, strength opposing strength, the collective power and the collective interest of one class opposing those of the other.

But in a Democracy, assumed to have attained complete a-cracy, the functionary wishing to exploit those over whom he has authority has no chance whatever. Whom is he to rely on for this purpose? There do not exist any longer opposing class-interests and class-conflicted, because the classes themselves have disappeared. Certainly it will still be possible for a functionary to become a criminal, but in an a-cratic Democracy he is deprived of all support and protection against the indignation of public opinion, for there will be but one public opinion, and not, as in a state divided into classes, as many as there are classes. It will still be possible that a functionary lead the whole social body astray causes it to follow a path that may prove disastrous, but he can never force the community to follow such a path. He is alone against the whole and undivided body of the people, powerful only when he executes the will of the people, when he furthers public interest, impotent whenever he might be tempted to try and act against the will of the people and contrary to the public interest.

This result of our analysis gives us at the same time the explanation for the exceptions we have mentioned. Authoritative government leads to exploitation whenever it can rely on the support of a whole class, which not only does escape this exploitative, but profits by it.

The so-called democratic states of Antiquity foundered on this reef. These states, divided into classes, had a double foundation: the closing-in of the land and slavery, and thus the division into classes was particularly accentuated, facilitating the machinations of all sorts of demagogues and pretenders.

These aspirants to public power could always rely on one class or another to support their claims, and the principle is still the same in modern Europe.

But where no division into classes prevails there, abuses of authority cannot be carried on with impunity and can certainly not be persisted in.

This being true, there vanishes the only argument that Oligocracy can put forward against the claims of Democracy—if we have out the preposterous pretention that authoritative government be a manifestation of the “will of God.’ That argument assumes that democracy must necessarily lead to Anarchy, to disorder and to chaos, thus confusing Anarchy with A-cracy. The state of the future, not divided into classes, the ‘free citizenship” of my terminology, meaning a charactership freed all remnants of political means will possess the most effective and most thorough authority; it will have its official functionaries, invested with all the power reasonably necessary; its system of taxes and contributions; its legal code; its judges and so on. Such a state will be utterly different from Anarchy and yet essentially A-cratic.

VI.

“Be that so,” someone may reply, “full democracy, according to your definition, is then possible when the very last vestiges of political means have been abolished, when the legal institution permitting the closing-in of the land has been done away with utterly. Then the division of classes and the state divided into classes will disappear. Such a community can last forever, because it can elect official and authoritative functionaries without fear of abuse of power. All that is very well. But now what proof is there that such a social condition is really desirable? After all we have here nothing more than one philosophical idea opposed to another philosophical idea, one ideal as against another ideal, one political theory against another. What is there to prove that the oligocratic concept is wrong and the democratic A-cracy right”?

To be Continued.