The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 5 · November 1914
161printed page
scan 13 of 56
THE MACCABÆAN
161

institution that sanctions and guarantees the former oppression by violence. All division into classes must cease automatically and immediately the moment this legal institution is abolished. And this institution is the legal right to the closing in of the land.

So far as I know, it was Turgot who first stated that only where "every piece of land has found its master," can a labor class come into existence, and it is the existence of a labor class that alone makes possible unearned income, latifundiary property and the excessive hoarding of "capital"; because all this presupposes the existence of a class without property, of a class of "free" laborers, to use the terminology of Marx.

We know that long before the time of Turgot all the land had found an owner, for there existed already then, and even earlier, a labor class, unearned income and large fortunes. The question is: How had the land found its owners? Had it been taken possession of by economical means? That is, had the ownership been acquired by peasants, tilling the soil with their own hands and reaping what they had sown themselves? Or had the political means been employed? That is, had the ownership been acquired with a view to closing in the land and to forcing others to pay the owners part of the produce of their labor?

Neither Turgot nor any of his successors, except perhaps the Irish socialist, Thompson, have approached this question. Not one of them has come to the conclusion that this fact can be explained in two different ways. They concluded, quite simply, that no divisions into classes and no latifundiary property could possibly exist if there were enough land available. But as the existence of the one and the other had to be admitted, there evidently was not enough land.

This conclusion is wrong. It overlooks the fact that indeed there might be enough land to go round, but that it might be closed in by the right of ownership against those that need it. Should this be the case, then the consequences, as far as social class-distinc-

tions go, must be the same as if there were not enough land.

How shall we decide this question? Quite simply by the use of arithmetic and statistics. We must find out how much land is necessary to support one peasant, how many people there exist today needing land, and what the total area available for agriculture is. If we discover that we are short of land, then the division into classes is an imminent category of human society, and the existing order of states divided into classes is immutable. But should we find the available area to be in excess of the needed acreage, then the division into classes is the consequence of a legal institution, the consequence of the closing-in of the land, and in that case the state divided into classes as existing today is a historical category, the result and the legal casing of the political means.

The operation, if carried out, proves beyond a doubt that the second assumption alone is correct by the same author: Die soziale Frage und der Sozialismus (the social question and socialism) Gustav Fisher, Jena.—I have gone fully into these details in one of my books, and therefore I may be allowed to content myself here with only a short summary of the facts.

According to the opinion of competent authorities, the area necessary to permit a family of peasants to live by the produce of their agricultural labor can be set down as being in Germany one hectar per head (2% Engl. acres), five to seven hectars (12% to 17% Engl. acres) per family, striking a liberal average. This area allows a thoroughly reasonable standard of life; the net income will be in the East of Germany more than 300 marks ($75) per hectar market-value that is saleable produce after deducting the part of the peasant, his family and his animals have consumed. Moreover, this is still far from the possible maximum. The yield can be considerably augmented by special attention being given to cat- tie raising, as is proven by the examples of Denmark and the north of France. At the same time this acreage is the maximum that a peasant family can cultivate properly with the average