The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 4 · October 1914
124printed page
scan 8 of 34
Facsimile · scan 8 of 34
Scan of p. 124
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE WAR AND THE JEWS

By Jessie E. Sampter

Eight countries are at war. Of these countries, everyone will suffer no matter what the outcome of the struggle. But some will be victorious, and to these the loss in property and happiness will be offset by the joy of national self-aggrandizement. Some countries will be defeated, and for these will remain bitterness of spirit as well as material suffering. But even these defeated ones will fall back for consolation upon national feeling and a sense of worthy sacrifice.

There is one people, however, scattered among all these nations, which has to pay all the tolls of battle, and yet to whom victory and defeat are alike a national calamity. These are the Jews.

Whatever the Jews may consider themselves, and whatever they may be considered here where the national population is still in the making, it is clear that in Europe the Jews are looked upon as an alien people. Therefore, no matter how welcome they may be as a commercial, industrial, or even cultural asset in certain of the nations, they are everywhere open to the prejudice, or at least, the suspicion, that confronts foreigners. Their traditions, the specific teachings of their religion, and the habit of loyalty learned in their staunch adherence to their own ideals, make of them loyal citizens of every country that gives them even a shadow of opportunity to show such loyalty. Therefore, at the outbreak of war, the Jews are among the first to enlist and to offer financial help.

Their foster lands are not only willing to accept this free-will offering, but also take some trouble to prove their great affection for the Jews. The Czar did this before in the war with Japan. He bought the Jews with promises. He is evidently repeating the bargain now, without making mention of his still outstanding debt. The German and Austrian military circles poured torrents of

anti-Semitic abuse upon the Jew. He was not a true Teuton, therefore, among other things, he lacked that exclusively Teutonic jewel, a sense of honor. Since war began, one hears nothing but tactful praise of Jewish courage. The son of Captain Alfred Dreyfus has already won military honors in the French army. Even liberal England has found it necessary to protest against recent anti-Semitic attacks in its journals. It has to reiterate that the English Jews are English. The answer itself proves the presence of the question. Everywhere the Jews are loyal and will be fighting. And every one admits in time of war, what is so often denied at other times, that the Jews, who naturally hate war, are desperate fighters when they do fight.

What is the result of war for the Jews? Already in Russia there stands out with ironic force the fact that the Czar has massed his beloved Jews on his borders as a buffer to the first Teutonic attack. Note the position of the Pale of settlement. He has used the Jews as a shield to protect Russia from the impact of war. Almost all of war's devastation in Russia must fall upon Russia's Jews. Both for those who dwell on this borderland perforce, and for those homeless ones who were on the march of migration and are now caught helpless and penniless between two hostile lands, the suffering is already incalculable. The people without a land—the luft manschen, as they have been called are crying for a place to set their feet.

And what after the war? In case of defeat, every alien who consumes food is a menace. The rage of the defeated has always vented itself upon the Jews. They are a safety valve for the wrath of Furonpe. We know what to expect.

In case of victory, Chauvinism, the intense national consciousness of thepeople also makes aliens unwelcome. Willthe Teuton or the Slav wish to sharetriumphs with the Semite?