THE WAR AND JEWISH RIGHTS IN RUSSIA
ITS EFFECT ON IMMIGRATION
By Isaac A. Hourwich
Soon after the outbreak of the war the press agencies friendly to the Allies spread broadcast the sensational report of an alleged proclamation of the Czar, in which he promised to his "beloved Jews" equal rights with all other Russian subjects. Russian newspapers which have since reached this country contain no mention of any direct appeal from the Czar to the Jews. The only reference to the Jews is found in the appeal addressed by the Commander-in-Chief of the Russian Army, Grand Duke Nicholas Nicholayevitch, to the Poles; it reads in part as follows:
"Under this sceptre (that of the Russian Czar) let Poland be reunited, free in her religion, language and self-government. One thing Russia expects from you—the same respect for the rights of those nationalities with which history has bound you."
It must be understood that the Russian word for "self-government" (samouprachonie) is restricted in common parlance, as well as in legal terminology, to local administration. It does not imply any legislative authority. Such a relationship as that which exists between Great Britain and Canada, or even between the Russian Empire and Finland, is described in Russian by the Greek word "autonomy." Still, if one is inclined to take an optimistic view of the situation, it be argued that unless the Poles were to be given the power to legislate in united Poland, it would have been purposeless on the part of Grand Duke Nicholas Nicholayevitch to urge upon them "respect for the rights" of the Jews.
So, by inference, the Poles are to have a government of their own and the future Polish government is relied upon to show "respect for the rights" of the Jews. In what legislative action this "respect" is to be manifested is not definitely stated. It may be inferred from
the language of the Appeal that the Jews are to be "free in their religion, their language and self-government." As it is impossible to imagine a concurrent Jewish government, alongside with the Polish government, it is evident that at most the Jews may expect, along with freedom of worship, the privilege to use their own language in their own communal administration, and probably a share in the "self-government" of Poland. There is no direct suggestion of civil and political equality in the words of that Appeal.
It must be borne in mind, moreover, that Poland holds only a minority of the Jewish population of the Russian Empire. What of the other millions of Russian Jews? The answer to this question was given, first by the Russian Ambassador in London and, next, by the Russian Ambassador in Washington. They both quite truthfully stated that no promises had been made by their government to the Jews.
Another story was told to an American correspondent by Mr. Herve, the editor of La Guerre Sociale. Immediately upon his conversion from an extreme anti-militarist to a French chauvinist, he went to see Mr. Briand, who himself had been an advocate of the general strike before he became Prime Minister of France. Mr. Herve called the attention of his old friend to the awkwardness of the alliance between France and Russia, so long as the Russian government oppressed the Poles and the Jews. Mr. Briand promised to intercede in their behalf with the Russian Government. And now, thanks to the initiative of Mr. Herve and the efforts of Mr. Briand, "the Jews are free," as the enthusiastic Mr. Herve assured his interviewer.
These myths are circulated in order to justify, before the public opinion of the world, the alliance between the two freest
