The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 3 · September 1914
92printed page
scan 16 of 42
92
THE MACCABÆAN

The criticism of the capitalistic system and economic individualism was the chief basis of Socialism. Socialism in these countries were confronted with the problem of the freedom and independence of all nationalities. Robert Owen, Fourier, Cabet Proudhan, the socialists of France and England in the first half of the nineteenth century, discovered only the weakness of modern society, and sought only to provide a rational scheme for the founding of a new social system. Pre-Marxian Socialism had merely been an effort of the human imagination to create an harmonious social system. All international political problems were ignored.

Beginning with the second half of the last century, Socialism, represented by Marx and Lasalle, conceived itself as a critical and creative movement, active within the bounds of existing society. It enlarged the sphere of its interests. But with regard to the national question it did not attain any grasp of the underlying facts. In the year 1848, the year of revolutionary reprisals, Marx displayed his great revolutionary and literary activities. ITe already grasped the truth that every nationality has the right of independent existance, cultir ral development and political freedom. But even Marx discriminated at that time between worthy and unworthy nationalities, between real nations and ethnographical units, whose only mission in history was to be absorbed and assimilated by other stronger nations. The test of the value of a nation was the degree of its comipliance with the ideals of Frronean democracv and the cause of revolution. To all the nationalities in Austria and Turkev. to the Servians. Bohenmans, Ruthenians. Slavontans, Croatians, Bulgarians, and others, Marx denied the right of national existence and was out of sympathr with their strugrgle for freedom. Tt is not even ohvions that Marx admitted at that time the rieht to national existance of the Russian pennle. then already evolving its doctrine af Pan- Slavısm and dreaming of world-power. Of the Slav nations, Poland alone secured sympathy from Marx because Poland in its struıggle for fredom weakened Rnssia, the shield of reaction and the menace of Erronean democracrv.

Marx was far from accepting the great moral principle of Kant. It is not surprising that Marx, estranged from Judaism by

education and conversion in childhood, never grasped the problem of Judaism and the Jewish nation. In the Jewish nation he saw nothing more than a group of rich merchants such as lived in his native city. Judaism was for him in the terms of Feuer- bach, the philosophy of practictl egoism. The God of Israel was Mammon. The so- Jution of the Jewish question was to be the Iberation of the world from Judaism. Karl Marx’s friend and co-worker in revolution, Moses Hess, found a very different definition of Judaism and another solution of the Jewish problem.

Lasalle in his approach to the national problem was practically a disciple of Marx. In his famous pamphlet on the Italian war (1859) he advocates the right of freedom and independence for every nation. But only such nations as were struggling for their forlorn national existence and which had attained historically a certain degree of culture and individuality were to be recognized as such. From this conception of nation is excluded the greater part of the Slavic peoples, the people of the Balkans and others. Lassalle repeated the old mistakes of historians and sociologists. His generalizations were based on temporary phenomena, and he gave to relative accidents absolute value and indentified isolated facts with evolutionary tendencies.

Free Nationality Not Recognized

In the history of modern socialism the problem of free nationality has never been treated with proper attention and the national struggles of the oppressed peoples have been regarded as a sort of necessary evil rather than as a manifestation of historic progress. The International Workingman's Alliance founded by Marx in 1864, declared itself in sympathy with the Polish revolution. In 1871 when Germany annexed Alsace-Lorraine, Marx protested in the name of International Socialism, and pronounced the prophetic warning that the humiliation of France would unite France with Russia and would provoke a future world war, a war of Germany against Russia on one side and the Latin races on the other side. We are now witnesses of the fulfillment of the prophecy.

Social Democracy in all countries particularly in Germany conceded only reluctantly the demands of oppressed nations