Tikvah, the Zionist was surprised to have the word "Tikvah" immediately prompt some of the girls to sing the air of "Hatikvah." They say a movement may be judged by its songs—but evidently not by its singers.
After the meeting, the house supervisor of girl's clubs, a Christian woman of broad sympathies, invited the Zionist to address another club of Jewish girls. "I want them to hear what you have to say," she said, "because I don't like their attitude towards Jewish subjects. Lately they had a college boy speak to them on Jewish history, but evidently he was suffering from too much American college."
Then said the Zionist. "I am going to tell you something with which I am sure you will disagree. I believe that all Jewish clubs ought to be led by Jews." She added the usual reasons, the close connection with the home-culture, the acquiring of American education through a Jewish source, and so forth. To her surprise, the Christian supervisor answered, "I thoroughly agree with you."
But when the Zionist later expressed the same opinion to her friend, the Christian club leader, it was resented almost as a personal affront. She answered "Very well. But I see it is Christians who organize the clubs. If you want Jewish club leaders, provide them. Where are they?"
The reproach was just. Where are our leaders? And when the Zionist sees how Zionism has filtered into every corner of Jewish life, how Zionists are allowed to be "graduated," how precious opportunities are wasted, then she would go farther and say all Jewish clubs should be led by Zionists. But where are our Zionist leaders? We ought to meet this opportunity and this responsibility: A Zionist leader for every Jewish club.
The only way we can begin to meet it is by self-discipline, by training ourselves for leadership, by corking some of our overflowing enthusiasm into the bottles of efficient work. A few active Zionists are worth many singers of Hatikvah.
What we need is a normal school of Zionism. Some years ago this need was recognized by Young Judaea, and Mr. Rueben Posner undertook the formation of several leaders training groups. They
are more in the nature of clubs than classes; they meet weekly; and any Jewish young man or woman is eligible for membership. They are more extensive than intensive in character, inspirational rather than technical. The courses consist of Zionism, club-leadership, Jewish history, and Jewish literature. The members of these groups have become active Zionists, and altogether the spirit in them is fine.
But some of us have felt the need of something else, to supplement these groups. We have been asked to speak in public on Zionism and to lead Zionist clubs, and we have felt technically weak. We have wanted to educate ourselves rather than make new Zionists--lest the work betray the workman.
A year ago one of the members of the Hadassah Chapter was asked to organize an experimental group for the study of Zionism. This group of six girls, between sixteen and twenty years old, was less firmly organized than Mr. Posner's groups. They met on Sabbath afternoons, talked over problems, and undertook work between meetings. Their conscious aim was leadership. They have done a large amount of practical work, chiefly for Hadassah, three of them are leading clubs at present, one of them has been active in committee work and has given a talk in public.
They all feel the need of more intensive study, of note-taking and definite training.
They should be the nucleus for a school of Zionism. That is what Hadassah is planning for the coming year, on a very small scale:—school of Zionism. But one must give the infant a name it can bear as a man.
We are going to begin with women’s classes alone, for three reasons: first, keeping in mind our ideal of intensiveness and thoroughness, we will begin with ourselves. Second, we are natur ally most interested in women’s work because that is our sphere, and we believe that classes of women can train for this work more quickly and thoroughly alone. And, thirdly, we believe the problems of club-leadership for boys’ and tor girls’ clubs are entirely different, and must therefore be dealt with separatelv. \We
