The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 1 · July 1914
6printed page
scan 6 of 46

organization welcomes co-operation of every nature in Palestine, but when opportunity offers, it will insist every time that things Palestinian must be done only in the way Zionists desire. Should this not set us thinking?

I willingly maintain the commendation I have heretofore made of some of the phases of Zionism, and to which Chairman Lipsky now makes reference, though I must complain it is not fair to take advantage of my commendation, as has been repeatedly done by the American Federation, and to suppress the utter condemnation I have upon every opportunity made of the so-called Nationalist efforts within Zionism, the promoters of which, in Palestine at least, if not elsewhere, appear to dominate the Zionist organization.

Chairman Lipsky is right, when, in referring to my advice that the further extension of support in things Palestinian be withheld, to apostrophize the words "for the time being," of which I have made use. No one will likely, as far as this can be done without detriment to the support which our home problems have the prior right to claim, favor more than I, active interest in and support of every cultural effort in the Holy Land and co-operation with Zionists for such ends, wherever the Zionist organization shall be willing to act with proper regard for other interests and divest itself of the baneful influence and domination, which its Nationalist wing seems to exert to so considerable an extent.

July 13, 1914.

JACOB H. SCHIFF.

The Jewish Daily News on July 10 contained the following editorial:

"The reply of Dr. Schmarya Levin to the attack of Mr. Jacob H. Schiff on the Zionists, because of the stand they have taken in the language question in connection with the Technological Institute at Haifa, has made clear at least one point, namely, that Jews of the diaspora who yearn and hope for the regeneration and the liberation of their people, could not, under any circumstances permit their language, the Hebrew language, to concede its place to German, on de-facto Jewish soil.

"We who feel and are convinced that

upon the rebirth of our people on congenial soil, and the development of a culture of their own, depends the existence of the Jew in the world, understand Dr. Levin’s reply. To us it is as clear as two and two. But will Mr. Schiff understand?

"We doubt it.

"From the very nature of the attack which he has made it is evident that the point is not clear to him. He does not understand it because he does not feel as we do.

"Mr. Schiff's style is the style of the ordinary philanthropist with a check book. He must have his will in the philanthropic enterprise to which he contributes. Mr. Schiff is a German Jew with the accent on the German. The German language is dear to him. He cannot conceive how Jewish Schnorrers, for whose benefit a "Technicum" is being erected should oppose German, or should dare express an opinion. Hebrew is foreign to him, and the spirit which animates the Jewish youth and stirs it to the highest sacrifices —that spirit is unknown to him.

"This is why we believe that Mr. Schiff will not understand.

"Mr. Schiff the great financier is certainly a very practical man. Far removed "Zukunftsplane" cannot appeal to him. He deals in realities. It must therefore have impressed him very strangely that Jewish-Schnorrers should reject or even jeopardize something of substantial value because of their foolish fancies about Hebrew. And like the genuine golus-philanthropist he speaks with the accents of the check-book. It is not worth while investing in an enterprise in which because of such nonsense the beneficiaries revolt.

"Keep your check book, Mr. Schiff! The Jewish people do not want it. Open it for the Schnorrers in golus, they are in need of it. A people is not helped by philanthropy. Search the pages of history and you will not find a single instance of a people liberated or regenerated by the rich. Rebirth and liberation must come from the people. Once on the way they will get there—it is only a question of time.

"And the Jewish people will also free you, Mr. Schiff, in spite of yourself and in spite of your check book.

"Recently a miserable libel was stirred