The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 1 · July 1914
4printed page
scan 4 of 46

relegated to the background for no other reason than to concentrate all attacks upon me. By eliminating both of them, it was intended to weaken at least by two-thirds the strength of our position. I am surprised that an experienced man like Mr. Schiff does not understand these tactics, and regret that in this instance an evil intention succeeded.

Now, for the issue itself.

A Technicum was built at the foot of Mount Carmel at Haifa, Palestine, for our Jewish youth. Russian, American and German Jews for the first time joined hands in brotherly fashion to create an international institution for the whole of Jewry. Every Jewish patriot—this term will offend no one—should have rejoiced. Thousands of our young men and women are being driven like beggars from land to land seeking an education and finding closed doors everywhere. We have seen their eager faces in Italy; they are to be encountered even in Spain and Portugal. For some of these exiles the Technicum was to be established. One Technicum would not answer the great problem of education for our youth; but we regarded the Technicum as a splendid beginning. We saw in it the first great act of Jewish self-help.

The project moved along smoothly until about the time for preparing for the opening of the school. The question arose, in which language should the students be instructed. The Palestinians argued: We have lived to see a Hebrew gymnasium at Jaffa, another at Jerusalem: we have passed through the critical period of childhood and have developed our language to such a degree that the graduates of Palestine schools are being received without difficulties in large universities in Europe and America. It should be possible—they argued—to have a Hebrew Technicum. Granted that for the first few years there will be hardships. The building up of the Hebrew Gymnasium at Jaffa was not so easy. Do you expect a nation to be reborn without birth-pains? And they argued further, with the Zionist leader: Shall we look to Paris or Berlin to take up our cause to be interested in our language? They looked to us for aid.

The position of the Zionist curators

was tragic. Our sympathies were wholly with the party of the young, creative generation in Palestine, but circumstances forced us, who were their only hope, to offer them a compromise, and what was our compromise, what did we ask for at the beginning? Let the truth be known. We Zionists asked that out of forty-five hours of study at the Technicum, Hebrew should be given nine hours or at least six. For instruction in German there would remain thirty-six or thirty nine hours a week. These were the demands of the dangerous Zionist agitators!

Not only did they refuse the six hours out of forty-five, but even in the preparatory school, where there could be no question as to the sufficiency of Hebrew for the Jaffa Gymnasium had developed a system of instruction in Hebrew, where more advanced studies, were taught than would be required in the preparatory school even there, as a concession, as an act of grace, we were to be permitted to use Hebrew only in teaching drawing, music and calisthenics.

The contest then began. First of all in Palestine, and throughout the world later, wherever the slightest interest existed for our land and our language. I do not desire to dwell upon the incidents of the struggle. I hope that ere long it will be described on a basis of genuine and not distorted documents, and that the Jewish world will then be convinced that it was one of the beautiful moments in our history. The incidental occurrences, few in number, which our opponents have deliberately selected for emphasis, will be forgotten, and there will remain the one outstanding fact that there was a time when Jews opposed the use of Hebrew in Palestine and that Palestine emerged victorious.

It is a pity that just now, when influential non-Jewish thinkers and statesmen have begun to admire the new Jewish life in Palestine, when the best and most influential journals of Europe express their surprise and wonder at the rebirth of Palestine—at this time, voices of opposition should arise out of the Jewish camp. But we hope that our present opponents will soon become better informed, and that their opinions will change, for we have no doubt as to their good-will. They are the victims of