estine we had created a type of Jew entitled to our respect and admiration.
This is what Mr. Schiff terms "reprehensible methods." And it is upon the basis of such a terrible misreading of the facts that he urges "international Jewry" to withhold support of the work of Zionists in redeeming Palestine by Jewish self-help. What mystic alchemy is it that effects Jewish action according to the geography of the stage on which it is performed? We Zionists do not preach American patriotism for American Jews, we believe that the environment of America works efficiently toward that end and that it is our duty to emphasize allegiance to Jewish ideals. But why should Mr. Schiff and his friends regard as reprehensible in Palestine that which Jews in golus are urged to do in order to be regarded as patriots?
And have American Jews been such generous contributors to Palestine that they already need a warning to check their generosity? Whatever has been done in Palestine, that has intrinsic worth, dignity and permanent value has been contributed hy the Zionists of international Jewry. We have contributed the men and women who have built up the colonies without a taint of Chaluka or philanthropy in their blood. American Jewry boasts of the Bible as its inheritance also. What has it done to redeem the Land of the Bible, the Land of the Prophets, what has it done to lift Jerusalem, the Holy City, out of its ruins? Is it statesmanship for a leader of Jewish action to advise “for the time being” that nothine further be done?
In the light of facts, we regard Mr. Schiff's statement as most unfortunate and most unfair to a movement with a record of achievement which he himself, in a more generous and fairer mood, thus eulogized:
“ It (Zionism) has proven to the gentile world that the Jew has not lost his self-respect: it has recalled to a far-reaching extent the Jew unto himself: it has, more than anything else could have done, shown him the value of his heritage. It has quickened the efforts to rehabilitate Palestine, and even if it cannot re-establish there a Jewish state... .it is at least effectively leading in the reclamation of the land of our birth from the slough of degradation into which it and a great part of its population had fallen.
LOUIS LIPSKY.Chairman, Executive Committee.Federation of American Zionists.
Three of the Yiddish daily newspapers opened their columns to Dr. Schmarya Levin for a reply, which Dr. Levin availed himself of, thus placing before the American Jewish people the Zionist view of the situation. Dr. Levin said, in part:
It was not until I had arrived in New York that I learned of the resignation of the American directors of the Haifa Technicum. The inference of the American Jewish press, as expressed in their comments on the incident, was that their resignations were due to the unfair demands of the Zionists. I could not understand how this conclusion was arrived at. For after we had accepted the compromise as offered by the American directors themselves, not one step had been taken by the Zionists that could have in any way irritated the parties to the controversy.
In his open letter to The American Hebrew, Mr. Jacob H. Schiff also found it necessary to blame the Zionists for having put obstacles in the way of the realization of the Technicum and by their reprehensible tactics jeopardizing its existence. He places the largest part of the blame upon me, and seeks to show, en passant, that it was not I who had secured his interest for the Technicum but Dr. Paul Nathan of Berlin.
First, I have never expressed my opinion to any one as to who had influenced Mr. Schiff in the matter of the Technicum. When a man contributes funds to an institution, his contribution is usually credited to his individual account. A double entry system in such cases is not gracious, and I sincerely regret that Mr. Schiff has approved of such a system by lending ear to petty gossip. I have too high an opinion of our philanthropists to believe that they are influenced by persons, and not by ideas and ideals. For in the matter of ideals or ideas, there is no copyright law—they are free to all.
More especially do I feel hurt that Mr. Schiff should wish to make it appear that it was I who influenced my colleagues, Achad Ha-am and Dr. Tschlenow, who resigned with me from the Technicum. I do not deserve this honor, and am in duty bound not to accept it. Achad Ha-am and Dr. Tschlenow are too well known in the Jewish world to need praise or recommendation at my hands. Each is, in his own way, a leader, and it would be impertinent if I ventured even to deny that it was my influence that led them to act as they did. The truth is, Achad Ha-am and Dr. Tschlenow were thus
