"Whereas the recent language struggle has called attention to the importance of carrying on the educational activities in Palestine under Zionist auspices, and
"Whereas a Jewish University is about to be established in Palestine,
"Be it resolved that the Actions Comite be urged to appoint a Central Bureau consisting of a committee in Palestine and representatives of the Federations, and
"Be it further resolved that all monies collected for all educational activities in Palestine be forwarded to the Palestine Schools Fund Committee, and
"Be it further resolved that all monies collected shall be distributed with regard to the needs of elementary, secondary and vocational institutions and life and labor in the land."
Mr. Frankel of Newburyport, Mass.: America cannot dictate the policy of Education in Palestine.
Mr. Fishman of New York: The adoption of such a resolution would result in a repetition of the Curatorium situation, and would also reflect discredit on the Actions Comite.
Mr. Cowen: It would not reflect discredit on the Actions Comite inasmuch as the Actions Comite never presumed to cope with this matter to any greater extent than was forced upon it. The demands made upon a Federation should not be greater than it can cope with, and the Federation itself can decide its capacity best.
Rabbi Kohn of Paltimore: The problems of Palestine education are national not local.
Miss Szold of New York: The resolution will not work to eliminate the Actions Comite. The power of Palestine education should not be vested in Palestine. So long as it is necessary to have a Zionist movement outside of Palestine, so long will it be necessary to have representation from the Golus.
Mr. A. B. Goldberg of New York: Although one can agree with the motives that prompt this resolution, objection must be taken to it. It is impossible for an international organization to attend to matters of education. The thing that can be done is to make a declaration of principles according to which these schools should be conducted and this, in
fact, has already been done by the last meeting of the Actions Comite. It is true that foreign countries should not serve only in the capacity of "purse" to Palestine, yet it is not within their province to interfere in activities not under their jurisdiction.
Dr. M. M. Kaplan of New York: The influence of the Federations would tend to transfer the currents of Golus life into Palestine, and defeat its own purpose.
Mr. Nowack of Louisville: The Actions Comite already being representative of the different Federations, the power to control Palestinian education vested in it, makes the resolution unnecessary.
Mr. Lewin-Epstein: Palestine should work out its own problems—whether educational or otherwise. Authority to dictate, if accorded to outsiders, will lend to the furtherance in Palestine education of an air of philanthropy. In Palestine itself there are Jews of all countries, and a national body could be formed in Palestine itself.
Mr. De Haas of Boston: The preamble to the resolution would obviate discussion. Motion made, seconded to read preamble.
Motion made, seconded. to reler resolution back to the Resolutions Committee. ior reconstruction. Carried.
Adjourned at 6 P. M.
THIRD SESSION.
(Jewish Young Men's Association, Monday, June 29, at 9:30 A. M.)
The Chairman had read the communications from Max Margolies of Cape May, Morris Neaman of Pittsburgh, Harry Caplan of Etna, Agudath Zion of San Francisco, Rabbi B. A. Litcher of Far Rockaway, Bernard G. Richards of New York, Congregation Ahawath Sholom of Fort Worth, Bnai Zion Alliance. Norfolk, Sons of Israel Lodge of Rochester, Toronto Zionist Council, Philip H. Bregstone, Zochrei Zion Gate, of Fargo, Rabbi Adolph Gold of Brooklyn, Zionist Council of Pittsburgh, Central Committee Poale Zion of America, Kadimah Society of Chicago, Zhaarai Zion and Zeierei Zion of Worcester, Hoachoozo One of Chicago, Atlanta Zionist Society, Hoachozo B of Chicago, Tifereth Zion of Lynn, Rev. H. H.
