The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 6 · June 1914
183printed page
scan 25 of 34
Facsimile · scan 25 of 34
Scan of p. 183
Text · transcribed from the scan

The success of the Zionist project struck fear in the hearts of many of the ultra-conservative, and the rabbis found themselves in a dilemma. They were confronted with the problem of reconciling the newly aroused national sentiment with the Messianic hope. The more orthodox vehemently opposed the new movement, declaring it to be contrary to Jewish tradition, especially when they saw Zionism numbering among its most enthusiastic adherents men who had long been estranged from Jewish rites and rituals. They feared that a second crisis impended over Judaism, which would again lead to a breaking away from the old established Judaism. Many of the more prominent rabbis, however, sympathized with and believed in the new movement. Men such as Samuel Mohilewer, Mordecai Eliashberg, his son Jonathan, Mordecai Joffe, and others, became enthusiastic leaders of the new movement, and lent their most assiduous efforts in its propagation. With the intention of gaining the co-operation of the ultra-orthodox, several theories were expounded in an attempt to reconcile the new nationalism with the Messianic hope. Kalischer's belief, that the Messianic era must be preceded by a settlement of Jews in the Holy Land became common and found many adherents. Others argued that, after having established themselves in Palestine, and rigidly conforming to all God's commandments and mandates, the Jews being worthy of redemption, then would God manifest the greatness of his mercy, Elijah and the son of David would appear, and the Messianic era would be inaugurated. Again others rejected any link between the new movement and the Messianic hope.

To speak of the Zionist movement without mentioning Theodore Herzl, its greatest exponent, would be sacrilege. His book, "The Jewish State" succeeded in flaming in the hearts of his brethren a burning desire for renationalization, and opened a new vista to them. In a most ingenious and practical manner the government

of a Jewish autonomous community, chartered by some government and assured of security by the powers of the world, is expounded. Although the feasibility of establishing a Jewish government in either Argentine or Palestine is discussed in his book, Herzl's closer study of Jewish life convinced him later that the Jewish consciousness is so indissolubly bound to Palestine, that no other location could be successfully considered. Further, although he wished to separate absolutely regal from sacerdotal rule, he recognized that the religious sanction of the people would be necessary to a renationalization. Strong and bitter denunciations of Herzl arose. His book was declared no more than a Utopian dream, and some went so far as to declare the author of unsound mind. It was asserted that none of the great powers of Christendom would concede the Holy Land to the Jew; that the high temperature of Palestine would not be conducive to health; that the location had poor prospects of becoming a commercial center and attracting Jewish capital; that the incongruous elements of which the Jewish state would be composed would not insure harmonious blending and stability; and further that so petty a state could at any time become the plaything of any hostile forces arrayed against it. Decried and calumniated on many sides, Herzl, however, continued unremittingly in his propaganda, and in the hearts of the masses his plans evoked an enthusiastic response. Several audiences were granted him by the Sultan, other monarchs of Europe discussed his rational and persuasive arguments, and several financiers of Europe lent their aid. His cause gained strength, and some of Europe's greatest intellectuals answered his call. Congresses were held, and the Zionist movement became a cogently concrete organization. Taking upon himself the most colossal tasks, standing ever as the upholder of his people's ideals, a martyr to his cause, Herzl's name