The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 6 · June 1914
169printed page
scan 11 of 34
THE MACCABÆAN
169

The Closing of Galveston.

The announcement is made that the Galveston Information Bureau will close its doors in October, thus ending an interesting experiment in the diversion of Jewish immigration. The reason given, however, is not illuminating. It is said, in the official announcement, that the Bureau is compelled to cease its activity owing to the unfavorable attitude which was reflected in the number of excluded aliens. More Jews were excluded from Galveston, in proportion, than from Fllis Island. But this should not have been an insuperable difficulty, and even if many were excluded, the necessity of doing this work should have overbalanced that discomfort. But whatever the reason for closing the Bureau, the Galveston enterprise, originated by Jacob H. Schiff, deserves praise for attempting something out of the ordinary run of Jewish philanthropy. Here at least the controlling idea was not submission but opposition to what seemed inevitable. Mr. Schiff wanted to take a hand in the immigration, and refused to countenance conditions that were bound, in his opinion, to make the general immigration more and more difficult. The natural inclination of the Jew from Europe is to go to New York, regardless of the problems there created. The Galveston idea was to persuade Jews to go to virgin territory, and thus prevent congestion in the sea-board cities. Naturally, this was uphill work. Sentiment for Texas was hard to create. The drift was always toward New York, and nothing could prevent the Jew from going to join his brethren, where his brethren were most numerous. Well, Mr. Schiff has given up the task. What will he do next? One constructive, statesmanlike idea deserves another.

The Ito Out of a Job.

The Jewish Territorial organization has been divorced from the Galveston work for some months, but the closing of the Bureau definitely ends its relation with what seemed to be its principal practical reason for existence. The Ito has claimed a great deal of credit for itself out of the Galveston enterprise, which served Mr. Zangwill frequently as a striking invitation to criticize the Zionist organization. In

fact, as Dos Yiddishe Folk points out, the Ito was nothing more than an instructed and subsidized agent in the Galveston work, the idea being Mr. Schiff's and the funds, at least on this side, being his. On the other side, the funds were also not Mr. Zangwill's or his organization's. The Ito has succeeded in creating the impression that it is a tremendously practical concern, thanks to Mr. Zangwill's great publicity talent, and Galveston was seized upon as being eminently practical. The closing of the Bureau will put an end to an immense amount of Ito talk, and it ought to serve to point the lesson of humility to that arrogant organization. At the Territorial conference, we learn, the Angola project will again be belabored with discussion, and Mr. Zangwill himself is reported to have suggested the co-operation of the Zionist organization with the Ito in Mesopotamia. The latter proposition is interesting, but with Palestine on our hands, it is questionable whether we can afford to lose time with Mesopotamia. At any rate, what will the Ito contribute to the partnership?

Georg Brandes' Dilemma.

Dr. Georg Brandes, the eminent literary critic, in his seventy-third year, visited New York this month, and received a welcome from newspapers which impressed him hugely, but there was a fly in the ointment, in that the Jewish newspapers persisted in alluding to an unpleasant incident in his life. It seems, according to his own statement, that once, having occasion to enter Russia, the eminent "Dane" went to the Russian consul to have his passport visced. When asked whether he was a Jew, Dr. Brandes was astounded. He thought, as he says, that every one knew that he was a Jew by descent. The question had never been asked of him before—by a Russian consul. Suspecting a pretext to exclude him from Russia, where he was the lecturer on Strindberg and other notable writers, he replied that he was not a Jew, having in mind that he never went to a synagogue, was not a believer, and that his own father had never gone to a synagogue. The Russian Consul regarded this reply as an evasion on Dr. Brandes' part, and refused to vise his passport. These are