rejected. There was no alternative but to return him to the United States, which held him at Ellis Island. The man was born in Russia, but had lett Russia without a passport, and no steamship company would take the responsibility of attempting to return him to Russia. What is to be done with this human being? He has a civic status nowhere. He belongs in the twilight zone where no law applies. In truth, he has no rights, for rights belong only to a person who has a legal status. This same condition applies to the Jews as a whole. They have no legal status, as a people must be defended by volunteer defenders, and they have no local habitation. They are here, there, everywhere, but in the eyes of law, they are nowhere.
Is it not time that all Jews realize what their status as a people is, and seek to remedy the fault?
The Education Fund.
Die Welt publishes a table giving the amounts contributed by the various countries to the Palestine School Fund. America apears seventh on the list, following England, South Africa, Germany and others. Of course, we may advance substantial reasons for this bad showing. Boris Schatz has been with us, Mayer Berlin, Franz Oppenheimer. Local causes have also prevented us from making extensive public propaganda for this fund. But these are excuses in extenuation of neglect. The one good reason that may be advanced is this: The work for the Fund will require adequate planning, and systematic work, freed from polemics. Such work could not be done here while the controversy was going on. Now, however, the controversy is closed. Dr. Nathan has issued his account of the proceedings, and the Actions Comite has published its version. The Jewish public may now judge with a calm mind. Undoubtedly, we Zionists prefer the statement issued by the Actions Comite. It is by far the better account. It sounds true, and breathes a loftier spirit. Now is the time to begin operations. We shall have to raise at least $20,000
per annum. This large fund must be secured from all those who are interested in Hebrew education, with the Zionists in the lead. A committee has been appointed by the Federation. I will probably get to work at once. This would be a fine opportunity to penetrate into the religious organizations of the country, for they, of all Jewish institutions, should respond to the call of education for Palestine in the Hebraist spirit. All Zionists should consider that they have a duty to become annual supporters of the Palestine schools. Zionist societies should make their pledges in the form of annual self-imposed taxes.
The Annual Meeting of the Hilfsverein
The annual meeting of the German Hilfsverein was held on April 26, at Berlin, and the occasion served to evoke from Dr. Paul Nathan a plausible appeal for harmony in the Palestine education affair. Dr. Arthur Hantke, member of the Actions Comite, echoed his sentiments, and tactfully pointed out that the Jews of Palestine would like peace too, but that peace should be established upon a fair understanding and appreciation of the legitimate demands of Palestine Jewry. The controversy, as such has ceased. Three Zionist members Dr. Weitzmann, Leo Motzkin and Elie Strauss have been added to the Curatorium of the Haifa Technicum. We understand that there are other difficulties yet remaining to be adjusted. One of the difficulties arises out of the persistence of Palestinian Jews in avoiding the Hilfsverein schools. This is regarded by Dr. Paul Nathan as a boycott, and the boycott must be lifted, in his opinion, if real peace is to come. But there is no power that can remove the impression made by Hilfsverein tactics in Palestine. The prevailing sentiment, based on local conditions, is against the Hilfsverein. In fact, it remains for the Hilfsverein by its own actions to remove the antagonism of the mass of the population. Let it be seen that it has veered in the direction of Hebrew; that Hebrew teachers are being sought; then there will certainly be no prejudice, and peace will soon come.