this are blind willfully. Some such solution of the problem as that foreshadowed in the Zionist outlook seems necessary and desirable—if there is to be any outlook left, and if “the remnant that returns” is to be worthy of its issue. It has been said in another connection that a people that has had a great past, if it is to have a correspondingly great future, must also have a great present. For this great present Zionism is working, in order that Judaism may have a a still more glorious future. And in this sense Zionism and Judaism become one and the same.'
This brief account of Zionism answers a positive want which has been felt within the ranks for some time. With discussions concerning political, practical, Mizrachi, Palestinian, and Poale Zionism afloat, each with its own serious and all-important air of accomplishment, it was a matter of embarrassment for an ordinary body to decide just where Zion was situated. It needed some one to gather up the many threads and to hold them up to view with a steady hand so that it could easily be seen that they were threads—and that there was something big and visible behind them all.
It is bound to be complained that the book is too rigid and wanting in those soft touches which constitute a pleasant book. Prof. Gottheil’s apparent restraint is due, we believe, to the care that he. as a personal witness of the things which he describes, had to exercise in order to avoid the personal touch the presence of which might deprive his work of force and dignity. The Jewish Publication Society should be commended upon the selection of the writer for the task of describing the first of the “Movements in Judaism.” Prof. Richard Gottheil was an early associate of Herzl: he has therefore been able to reproduce in an excecdr ingly interesting and instructive work the original life which colored the progress of Zionism. co
S. R.
“The Haskallah Movement in Russia”
By Jacob S. Raisin, Ph.D., DD., Jewish Publication Society
The subject is in this work divided into six periods. In the first, “The Pre-Haskallah Period,” we find the Jews occupy-
ing a rather influential and honorable position in Russia. The "Russian brand of persecution" did not start until the eighteenth century. During this period which started indefinitely and continued to the year 1648 Russian-Poland became the "Aksanyeshel Torah" or the Jewish center of learning toward which large numbers of German-Jews flocked. The Jews distinguished themselves not only in the study of the Talmad but also in scientific pursuits. Dr. Raisin writes: "From the meagre data at our ' disposal we are justified in concluding, that, left undisturbed, the Slavonic Jews would have evolved a civilization rivalling, if not surpassing, that of the golden era of the Spanish Jews. But this was not to be. Their onward march met a sudden and terrific check." Hetman Chmielniki who with the aid of a horde of Russians and Tartars conquered the Poles also massacred about one-half a million Jews, besides crippling their communal life.
The second period, "The Period of Transition," extends to the year 1794. The first part of this period was one fraught with tortures and the most horrible intellectual deformations which are the concommitants of excessive torture. Mysticism became rampart. "Messiah" after "Messiah" revealed" himself as one promised to redeem Israel from all his troubles. These excesses were followed up by the establishment of Hasidism by Israel Baal Shem, the first of a famous triumvirate of this period. Then, also, worked Elijah of Vilna or "The Aaon of Vilna" the second of the triumvirate, who shed a powerful searchlight on all branches of Jewish study and proved a strong influence on the growth of Haskallah. The third was no other than the famous Mendelsohn. Other celebrities of this period were Maimon and Harwitz. The character of this period is best described in the author's words: "Fortune, indeed, has cast them also into a cavern, and they are groping around darkly. But this prisoner, too, is a giant, and he will at length, burst forth as a giant into the light of day."
“The Dawn of Haskallah,” the third period, extended to the year 1840. The first part of this period witnessed a renewal of tolerance of the government
