We shall then indeed have a "Brotherhood of Man," but supplemented by a Sisterhood of states, constituting a federal government that we might fittingly call: "The United States of the World."
Socialism, as interpreted by many of its modern leaders in Continental Europe, harmonizes with Internationalism, for within each separate state the Socialist voters, will have ample opportunity to work for the establishment of industrial democracy, while all the Socialists of the World may unite—not to abolish states, nations and races, but—to bring about Universal Peace through a World Confederation of nations, in which each people will preserve its own character and lend its own peculiar tone in the World Symphony. In such a view, Socialism, as an economic and political force, can have no opposition to Zionism. The latter is pre-eminently a Jewish National movement. The questions of Socialism, Single Tax, Imperialism or any other great moral and social issue can be settled in the Jewish State, when it is established, or by the pioneers who are daily fashioning the future Hebrew Commonwealth.
And yet, critics may justly ask of us: what kind of a state are you building? Will it be a duplicate of Autocratic Russia or a miniature United States? Will it become a restored Theocracy, comparable to the Hebrew Commonwealth in the days of Judah's Kings? or will it endeavor to realize some of the dreams of the greatest of social reformers—the Prophets of Israel.
We have in the Zionist Movement various parties. The Mizrachists place emphasis on the religious values in Jewish life. The Paoli Zion look forward to the upbuilding of a Jewish Socialist community in Palestine. Besides these, we have the various ko-operative groups, under the influence of Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, who accepts only partially the theories of Socialism, advocating, as the fundamental principle of his program, a modified Single Tax regime in the land of our forefathers. Zionism, therefore, can have no quarrel with Socialism, because it draws an important group of its adherents from Socialist ranks, even as it can have no opposition to the Mizrachists, no matter what religious interpretations they may place upon our movement. We are building a
"House of Israel," and those who are anxious that the structure shall show a certain kind of stone and marble are free to join us with the assurance that their labor will influence the texture of the completed edifice. We need all the sons of Jacob for our task, so long as they be true to the ideal of a Jewish nation on a Jewish soil, whether they come to us by the direct method of the Shulchon Orach or by the devious ways of the radical reformer. Zionism, therefore, both as a practical measure and as a philosophy of life, is not in opposition to any social reform or political program.
It is my firm opinion that if our Orthodox Zionists should search deep enough in Jewish history, they must conclude that Judaism, as a religion, and the Jews, as a people, are in harmony with every sane movement for social justice. On the other hand, let but our Socialist Jews open their eyes wide enough to admit a few facts besides the "economic interpretation of history" and "the surplus labor value," and they will learn that Zionism is a philosophy of life in which all that is really valuable in Socialism is recognized and appreciated. The Jew is now, and always has been, the great social factor in history. While the early Christians prepared for a life after death, neglecting civic duties and placing all the emphasis on individual salvation and individual immortality, while Europe went mad with an excess of individualism under Feudalism, the Jew held forth the banner of social salvation, of the unity of Israel second only to the unity of God. A large portion of our prayer book is devoted to prayers for the "People of Israel." From this point of view, the Jew is a socialistic factor in history—he has striven for social rights as distinguished from individual rights, for social reforms rather than for reforms of individual character. In these latter days, he has produced a Karl Marx and a Lasselle rather than an Anthony Comstock; he has given to the world labor leaders rather than Prohibitionist agitators.
Zionism, reflecting the national character of the Jew, must be socialistic rather than individualistic; it must partake of the social reform spirit of Isaiah rather than the other-worldliness of the Popes or the excessive individualism of Luther.
