too in this country, instead of meeting opposition in a straightforward manner, we have frittererd away our strength in creating subsidiary forms of Jewish organization intended to get at indifferentism where it can least resist attack. On the theory of "going into the communities," or on the theory of Hebraic culture being essential if Zionism is to make any headway, a number of our influential Zionists have adopted a golus program which absorbs them and makes it impossible to concern themselves ' with direct Zionist work. They presume that Zionism must have a Hebraic background in the golus lands, but forget that if the corner stone of that culture is not consciously national, it serves only to delay the success of Zionism. It is a fundamental assumption of our movementt that assimilation cannot be permanently checked in golus; that a national culture on national soil is the only alternative to the submergence of the Jews as such. But these friends have gone ahead, taking with them many of the rank and file, who have tackled the tremendous problem of education, communal organiation, Hebraic culture among students, etc. Their activities have resulted in immediate loss to us of persuasive personalities.
III
These, in general, are the aspects of Zionist organization. I treat them briefly, preferring not to enter into details or side issues or remarks, for, on the eve of our seventeenth convention, we American Zionist must tackle the concrete problems that have arisen not by projecting details, or wandering away into abstract thinking, but by looking at them against a broad horizon.
In truth, we have had few conventions that deserved the name. Years ago, problems were disposed of by leaders, who, acting in true Herzlian fashion, decided things for themselves in line with what they regarded as right and proper. To-day, we have gone ahead. The Federation is based upon an intelligent democracy. The administration attempts only to guide the rank and file of daily workers. It imposes nothing upon its constituency, being prepared to discuss all propositions openly in convention assembled.
If we are to make any progress, in
America, as well as in Europe, this must be the principle guiding our operations.
The Zionist forces must work along the lines of concentration of effort and control, as against scattering of effort and division of control. Not funds, but a fund. Not organization, but an organization. Not results, but a result.
At Berlin headquarters, this means: Not various agencies in Palestine, but one agency devoted to each national job. A Palestine Amt should be the Department of Agriculture, and in it should be all agricultural experts resident in Palestine, controlled by one member of the Actions Comite. We have taken up the problem of education. That means at once the preparation of a Department of Education, composed of Palestinian educational experts, controlled by one member of the Actions Comite. It is evident that industry is the next step in Palestine, for agricultural development must have industry as its auxiliary. Preparations should be made at once for industrial investigations, and plans laid for a Department of Industry, which shall be organized in the same manner. The Department of Foreign Affairs has been wholly neglected; it seems to have disappeared. It should be resuscitated with an expert board, also working under the control of the Actions Comite.
In other words, the organization must be planned upon broad lines. All funds and institutions must be established in clear relationship to the central organization, and the plan should allow for expansion on similar lines throughout.
In this country, this principle would lead to the following: The Federation would be the one recognized branch of the international organization in this country. In it would be included all parties, all semi-Zionist organiation, all societies devoted to special work in Palestine. Strict discipline would be enforced, for access to Berlin would be denied any organization or society of contributors if they do not observe the rules. All detailed propaganda would be classified and co-ordinated and combined. Land investments, industrial enterprises, literary propaganda, organization, speakers. We should not have Mizrachists coming to this country with the sanction of the Actions Comite, and organ-
