WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE ZIONIST ORGANIZATION IN AMERICA?
Zionism has become the irresistible movement in Jewish life, carrying in its wake all elements of the Jewish people. In every quarter there is a stirring among the dry bones. Palestine has worked this miracle, but behind Palestine stands the motive for the work, the desire for the rebirth of Jewish nationality. The motive is masked, but it animates all phases of our endeavor. More or less, it is there. There are many who do not look beyond the result. They commit themselves to Palestine, to Hebrew education, Jewish art, colonization, and believe they retain their theoretic opposition to Zionism. But deeds outweigh theories. An act is judged not by what the actor regards as his "reasons", but by its logical and psychological implications.
But if Zionism is irresistible, that does not mean it is bound to succeed. We are in danger of smashing the entire edifice by not taking precautions for the docking of our ship of state. The ship is all right, but what if the captain steers it upon the rocks?
The danger lies in an uncontrolled, helter skelter invasion of Palestine. This may sound fantastic, for what does Palestine work actually amount to? But those who have eyes can see the beginnings of a formidable Palestine movement, with all sorts of practical enterprises, set in motion by all sorts and conditions of men. They are already sending out their agents from America, from Russia and from England.
We have not created the machinery to control Palestine or to attempt to remove in a real, national sense the political difficulties that stand in the way of economic or cultural success and these political difficulties will disclose themselves in proportion as the movement grows. The colonization in Palestine is not in our hands, but is left practically to individual vagaries.
Herzl had the matter clearly in mind. You cannot enter Palestine without a legal standing, unless you are prepared for
an unformulated struggle with the government in power. There were two steps confronting the organization. They could not be taken simultaneously. The first was to secure the means to enable him to negotiate with the owners of rights in Palestine. The second step, to be taken after these rights had been secured and assured, was a colonization movement on a large scale guided by a competent corporation, furnished with the means to investigate, lay plans and direct the entire movement. The idea in the back of Herzl's head was an ex-territorial or super-territorial nationality directing the conquest of the land. Rights first, colonization second.
The circumstances have now altered. Herzl himself had to amend his own plans. He had failed to provide for the exercise of the national muscles in the interim between obtaining the rights, and the moment of large colonization. Jews inspired by Zionist propaganda could not be kept out of Palestine. The slightest occupation of Palestine was used as a lever for a further advance. The propaganda fed on Palestine. It was obsessed by slight advantages. It was consumed by the interminable details of a colonization and an activity which, to be economical and efficient, should have had an organization behind it so strong as to master the Palestine sentiment created. To control the situation, the organization should have become more powerful than the instruments of colonization. But not having attained its political objects, not in person being the creator of the conditions, but merely the inspiration of the creators, the organization became less and less than the works it inspired. To-day the organization is, in a sense, the rear guard, the useful friend, the "aunt" who is esteemed according to the funds she contributes.
The Zionist organization has thus merged its two functions. It is both the inspiration and the colonizer. It shifts