Whatever our desires may be, Jews cann now be kept out of Palestine. It would be folly to create a tremendous sentiment for Palestine, and not at the same time prepare to intervene in whatever developes in Palestine. The charter idea, the method Herzl hoped to employ to secure national recognition, is now obsolete. Dr. Nordau admits that. Then other means must be sought to secure what political negotiations have thus far not been able to secure. If Jews settle in Palestine, the Zionist organization, as the instigator of the settlement must be prepared to act in place of the government which the charter was to have called into being. It is not to act on behalf of individuals, but the public is entitled to know from the Zionist organization: Wha* kind of a country are you advising us to enter —what are its resources; its laws; its customs; its dangers? The responsive Jewish public is entitled to have provided for them such facilities as in other countries are provided by enlightened government. If schools are to be established, and it is possible for the Zionist organization to provide them, it must be done, for schools are a national asset. It is true, we are dealing with a government which is yet to give us recognition, but the same risk the individual takes, the organization must also be ready to take.
What is National?
Ix other words, Political Zionism must acyuiesce in the peaceful penetration of Palestine as long as political conditions are unfavorable. The movement must continıe as a movement. But the difference of opinion arises as to what is national and what is not. A man like Ussichkin, unfamiliar with or unappreciative of the meaning of political government, asserts that every thing Jewish in Palestine has national value. Ten men settled in Galilee. ten in Judea, a kindergarten in Jaffa, a soap factory near Haifa,—all these items taken together or separately are of national value. This would be true if the Zionist organization were on the spot acting with international consent as the de jure government. And even then. the government could not act as the supporter or the almoner of all these individual enterprises. The national in the true sense, as the term is to be used by us under present conditions. is that which government is expected to take
under its wing, that which government is expected to do for its constituents as a whole. A colony like Rechoboth may be able to provide its own schools, but it cannot provide text-books. Jerusalem cannot provide for its own water supply, for that is a matter beyond its municipal rights. The Zionist organization could and should step in to make good the deficiency. If the schools are to be united with one control, animated by national aspirations, the Zionist organization is the one agency that can establish the system. Pending the recognition of the Jewish nationality, a straight line could be drawn between what is national and what is individual, and on such a basis the Actions Comite deserves praise or blame to the extent in which it has diverged from the straight line. At least, that is what the Political Zionists should do, if they are capable of drawing such a straight line.
The Right Sort of Criticism.
From the foregoing paragraph, which only briefly sketches the line of reasoning which political Zionists must take, it is evident that there are a number of enterprises of the Actions Comite that may be criticised. For example. the building of Tel Aviv by Zionist funds advanced to private persons, by whom the advances are being repaid. This was, in spite of its benefits wholly uncalled for in the manner it was done. The National Fund principles should have been invoked. The land in Palestine insofar as the Zionist organization is concerned, must be nationalized, and it is ultra vires for any Zionist corporation to give its financial assistance for the development of real estate which is to be made the foot- hall of land speculation. There may have been good reasons for aiding in the upbuilding of Tel Aviv, good national reasons, but on the face of it Tel Aviv is one of the instances of Zionist funds being loaned out for private purposes. Quite otherwise was the effort made to build up the Oppenheimer ca-operative colony. There, a national work was undertaken. But in the main what the political Zienists seem to Jack is a program which touches reality. Until they are able to formulate such a program, many political Zionists in America will be forced to withhold their support of the new old group.