The★MACCABAFAN★
ISRAEL GOLDBERG, Editor
Vol. XXIV
APRIL 1914
No. 4
REVIEW OF THE MONTH
The Palestine Schools.
CIRCUMSTANCES have placed the burden of national Jewish education in Palestine upon the shoulders of the Zionist organization. Probably if our line of march were planned by us, in a perfectly logical manner, education would have been left entirely to the Palestinians, but nothing in Zionism arises in agreement with preconceived ideas. As one of us said, the roof must be laid before the walls are raised. The conflict with the Hilfsverein has brought about the necessity for the Zionist organization to guard the national character of Jewish education in Palestine. It is not a work of our seeking, but it has come to us; and as responsible and loyal members of the organization, appreciating the situation, we must do our best to respond to the appeal of the Actions Comite.
Dr. Nordau’s Paris Speech
DR. MAX Nordau's speech delivered in Paris last month is disappointing. It is not the address of the head of a party which held, according to report, an important conference only a few weeks before. It is a criticism of the administration, but reveals no program. The politicial Zionists have not shown remarkable political acumen or argumentative skill in their encounters with the Inner Actions Comite. In fact, the Inner Actions Comite is more skillful. What is all this pother about political Zionism? Why do not the political Zionists define it in the light of immediate conditions? A party is to be seen in what it attacks and in what it approves. And in this respect, Dr. Nordau's speech is lamentably weak. Why
should he attack the Actions Comite for its position with regard to the Palestine schools? He chooses to criticise the Comite on the ground that it has assumed a burden which it will be unable to carry, it has not kept the accounts straight, etc. But these are details and have nothing to do with the principles involved. Do the political Zionists repudiate the assumption of this burden? There are many political Zionists, not in the inner circle of the social Political Group, who believe education to be a function of government, and to that extent entitled to the attention of the Zionist organization, which is to act, in their opinion, as the defacto Jewish government in all national matters where that is possible. For this reason, they would approve of what the Actions Comite has done in the school controversy. They would not only approve of it, but they would endorse the militant stand taken to repulse the efforts of foreign invaders, who wished to put the stamp of alienism upon Jewish enterprise in Palestine. Is it wisdom, then, for the spokesmen for Political Zionism to take such a hopelessly indefensible position, wholly out of harmony with the principles of their own program?
What Political Zionism Stands for
It is evident that Political Zionism does not stand for the "waiting without" policy. Zionism is untenable unless it meets the condition it is bound to face of not being able at once to realize its ultimate object of national recognition, with some thing positive. Zionism must formulate its ideas regarding the Jewish population in Palestine, regarding those Jews stimulated by Zionist agitation to move into Palestine.
