The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 4 · April 1914
118printed page
scan 24 of 34
118
THE MACCABÆAN

method had been announced by Herzl himself as the basis of future colonization work. Since the above mentioned remarks have gone the round of the Jewish press we consider ourselves compelled to make the following statements in the interest of the cause.

In the first place it is to be noted that the figures as mentioned by Dr. Nordau do not correspond with the facts. It is not true that at the Hamburg Congress 100,000 frs. were subscribed of which afterwards only 25000 were paid. As a matter of fact about 40,000 frs. were subscribed which were paid in the course of the first year with infinitesimal exceptions. The entire capital raised by the propaganda campaign for the Co-operative Society amounted to, after deduction of all propaganda expenses not, as is given above, 125,000 but 145,000 frs.

After half a year's preparation in which time it was necessary to take definite possession of the land, the normal agricultural work began in October, 1911. The reproach that the official reports have become silent is not sound. The balance for the first agricultural year 1911-12 (5672) was reported duly and according to the statutes to the board of Directors at the General Meeting. The balance for the second agricultural year 1912-12 (5673) is already at hand and will be laid before the general meeting of the Co-operative Society to be summoned for May this year. The Management of the Co-operative Society has been at all times ready to give any information desired to the holders of share certificates and participation shares who were interested in the state of the farm.

At the request of the Directorate Dr. Franz Oppenheimer undertook a tour of inspection in the spring of 1913 to Merchawja and made a public report in a detailed series of articles in the Welt on his stay there and the state of things prevailing in the Co-operative Settlement Society Merchawja. Since then the pamphlet "Merchavia" by Franz Oppenheimer has appeared in English and Yiddish in New York and announced in the papers. (Vide also essay of the Central Office of the JNF "The Co-operative Settle Society Fund" in No. 10 of the Welt of the 6th March.

Both agricultural years have concluded with a deficit. The reasons for the losses sustained will be discussed at the next general meeting by the management and made accessible to the public. The report will show, that the assertion that the undertaking is a failure is without foundation. It is true that we had to make sacrifices of life and property. But this will be understood, when it is remembered that in Merchavia the problem is one of new land of which the Jews never before owned an inch. Our labourers and guards had above all to do PIONEER WORK and to overcome unusual economic and extra-economic difficulties. Two attacks by hostile tribes deranged the normal agricultural work both years. In addition to this in the last agricultural year there was a devastating plague of mice. Want of decent dwellings, of a plant supplying wholesome water and serviceable farm buildings has cost men and animals untold days of sickness. These attendant phenomena in the opening of a new colonization territory are invitable and cannot be put down to the co-operative settlement society's method of agriculture.

In addition to these extra-economic interruptions which scarcely allow the agricultural work in both years to appear as normal it must be emphazied that a mordern wholesale undertaking that in Merchavia must certainly reckon with losses in the first few years. With all the fruitfulness which the plain of Jezreel enjoys the land has been worn out by the primitive Arabian methods of work throughout the centuries without receiving any additional strength. even a layman must see that three to five years are necessary to make such land "capable of cultivation" by giving it the necessary manures.

It is all the more satisfactory that the co-operative work in Merchavia belongs to the best organized and most modern wholesale undertakings in Palestine according to the testimony of experienced and objective experts, and that the managers there in both years have exactly kept to the budgets drawn up. Contrary to the pessimistic view above quoted, we can state that both the workers and the management look forward to the future development of the Co-operative Settlement Society with perfect confidence. The rare devotion of the