hitherto, private enterprise and philanthropy both have been powerless to create the conditions that would attract Jews without means, (and it is just these Jews who would constitute the largest element in extensive colonization) and that would provide for their training.
Advantages of Co-operative Colonization.
The evils attendant upon Jewish landownership in Palestine can be estimated not by appeals to the ethical and patriotic sense of private investors, but by the introduction of a positive factor of economic and national value. Where a nation is normally situated, this task is performed by the State. In the case of the Jewish People, it devolves upon the National Fund and its auxiliary funds. It was for these reasons that it was resolved by the most authoritative Zionist body, the Congress, at Hamburg, to include co-operative colonization in its program, in order to pave the way for the solution of a most difficult problem. It would take us too far afıeld to recount here all of the reasons why co-operative colonization seenis superior to all other methods of settling those without means. (See Macc., Feb., 1914). The co-operative society affords the urban workingman an agricultural training, adapting its activities to the specific character of its members, while at the same time abolishing the paradox of Jewish ownership plus non-Jewish labor,—a condition as unwholesome from the national point of view, as it is incompatible with Jewish social solidarity.
The co-operative association combines the technical advantages of extensive operations with the intensiveness of small-farming and the promptings of self-interest. The co-operative society, basing itself upon the hereditary leasehold, assures the labor of the full fruits of his toil, without permitting him, as under the philanthropic methods, to reap the benefits of others' labors. The co-operative combination, with the other
factors already mentioned, will serve to increase the productiveness of the farms. And, when it is demonstrated that farming in Palestine with Jewish labor is profitable, the values thus created serve as a credit-basis for extensive colonization.
Merchavia, and Dagania: First Co-operative Experiments.
These are the aims of the Colonies Merchavia and Dagania, though they were originally conceived from different points of view. Merchavia was founded on the principles outlined by the protagonist of co-operative colonization, Dr. Franz Oppenheimer. Dagania was established on a somewhat different basis. The rate of progress of these colonies depends upon factors peculiar to Palestinian agriculture, as well as upon their working methods. People are apt to overlook the fact that our human material requires several years of preparation and training to transform city-dwellers into skilled peasants; and that several years' work is required to prepare Palestinian soil for European settlers. Soil plowed for thousands of years in the primitive Arabic manner and never manured or fertilized, must be put under modern cultivation for a considerable time before it can be made to yield sufficient for the needs of European laborers. Our laborers' associations, too, must pass through this pioneering stage. This work requires investments which can be expected to show profits only after the lapse of a number of years. The co-operative societies are obliged to limit themselves to simple farming for the first few years, and can only gradually take up more intensive cultivation and planting.
As a rule, the soil is prepared in advance for such undertakings. The Co-operative Settlement Society, however, was compelled to take possession of a tract of land which, while in the unquestionably fertile Valley of Jezreel, was nevertheless, unoccupied and unprepared, and had to be reclaimed at the risk and expense of the Society.