The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 3 · March 1914
69printed page
scan 7 of 34
Facsimile · scan 7 of 34
Scan of p. 69
Text · transcribed from the scan

REVIEW OF THE MONTH

Haifa Technicum Dispute Settled.

At a meeting of the Curatorium of the Haifa Technicum, held at Berlin on February 22, resolutions were adopted substantially in agreement with the demands of the Zionist organization. The resolutions, for the benefit of those who may have received garbled or partial reports on the matter, were the following:

"The course in mathematics and natural science will be taught in the Hebrew language with the opening of the Technicum. In all new contracts with teachers, a clause will be included in which the teacher will pledge himself to master the Hebrew language within four years of his appointment. At the end of the first four years' course of study, the Trustees will determine which subjects can then be taught in the Hebrew language. Their decision will depend upon the development of Hebrew and text books in the meantime. All members of the Administration Board must be consulted in the appointment of new teachers, a majority deciding. Three Zionists are to be elected to take the places of three members who resigned, two of whom are to be members of the Administration Board."

Following this decision, the Zionist organization nominated Leo Motzkin of Berlin, Prof. Chayim Weitzmann of Manchester and Julius Simon of Mannheim as its candidates to take the place of Messrs. Levin, Tschlenow and Ginsburg. Objection was raised to Herr Simon on personal grounds, and, we believe, Martin Buber was selected in his place. So much for the record.

Our Present Duty.

Some time will have to elapse before we shall be in a position to appreciate fully the problem that now confronts us. How we meet it depends wholly upon our strength and the wisdom of our leaders. Hitherto, our organization has regarded education in Palestine, exclusive of its national significance, as a matter for local organization.

Zionists have been called upon to support the Bezalel, the Jaffa Gymnasium, the Tachkemoni, but each of these institutions has operated on its own responsibility and in only a slight way controlled by the Actions Comite. The Bezalel recently was overhauled by the direct action of our administration. The Jaffa Gymnasium, however, and other schools, have conducted their own affairs in their own way. The Zionist organization assumed no responsibility nor had it any legal right to interfere in the management of these schools. The Technicum controversy has brought about the natural assumption by the Actions Comite of certain duties in Palestine education. Just as colonization has officially become a part of the activity of the Actions Comite, so now education seems also destined to be added to it.

On colonization work, there can be a difference of opinion only between the political Zionists still adhering to Herzl': plans and the practical Zionists. In educational work, a conflict of opinion is bound to arise with the Mizrachi party. The Mizrachists think that the Zionist organization should not involve itself in the culture of Palestine, leaving that to the initative of individuals or parties in Zionism. They are bound to protest against a policy of direct intervention in education, which involves religious traditions.

The Actions Comite will not, however, in our opinion, be able to resist the encroachment of this new interest. If there is tn be education in Palestine, subventioned Iv Zionists or Zionist sympathizers, it must more or less be controlled by the Zionist organization. In principle we must side with the Actions Comite, but as to how it is to exercise this control, involves fundamental distinctions, A thoughtless intervention, formulated on the run, so to speak. with bombardment by Palestine enthusiasm or Choveivi Zion impetuosity. will not do. The Actions Comite must here revert to its national traditions, to its heritage of Herzlian policy. Unquestionably, education is a national matter.