The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 2 · February 1914
49printed page
scan 17 of 32
THE MACCABÆAN
49

YOUNG IUDAEA IN THE PROBLEM OF JEWISH LIFE IN AMERICA

Some day, I believe, the appeals of an organization like that of Young Judaea will be better heeded and the little support it asks will not be denied it. This will be when the real significance of its activities in relation to the problems of Jewish life in America will become more apparent and the true value of its work among our young--and among ourselves better understood.

For Young Judaea does fill a lack, does bring something into the lives of Jewish children which neither the public schools, nor the Settlements nor the High Schools nor, I dare say, even the Hebrew Schools bring; and that thing is of a kind that is the most valuable that can be brought into the life of any nation. It is the high devotion which unconsciously begets that loyalty and eagerness of service in well-doing the attainment of which is the despair of all those drones who try to conjure them up in the young without themselves being enlisted in the service of a cause capable of calling them forth.

From the public schools it can hardly be expected that any hopeful influence can emanate tending to develop the Jewish character of our children. We are glad enough to be able to resist aggressive measures to assimilate them, such as crop up every once in a while even in such institutions in which the overwhelming majority of the pupils are Jewish.

If we take the Settlements, where a more liberal policy might be expected, we find in them the most signal instances of ignorant, unfeeling muddling in the minds and hearts of our young; and this in the name of civic improvement, culture, altruism and all the other incidents of the millennium of which the settlement is the self-constituted harbinger. And

it proceeds from this first sin: that the settlements have not sprung out of the will of the people themselves to create them, but were gifts coaxed from the surplus revenues of millionaires who placed those institutions in charge of persons of rather original social proclivities and fermenting in a vague, half-baked, pseudo-altruism of no definite complexion, yet easily attractive because easily borne.

The activities of the settlement as it is constituted at present cannot be successful in so far as they effect our young people. They will never create any positive types or produce any but sham values. For the settlement workers, either from ignorance or—as is often the case with the Jewish settlement worker—from hypocrisy or the fear of being compromised in his career of snobbishness, habitually ignores the origin, that is to say, the real centre of gravity, of his young charges.

The excellent Christian men and women who undertake this work remain totally in the dark with reference to the real psychology of the children they affect to lead. How can they lead them? They do not and cannot. They simply beam among them like so many will-o'-the-wisps, making, it is true, some impression with their elegant, manor-born kindness and gentility, but it is an impression which dazzles rather than enlightens.

What good does it do our children to be petted and pampered in externals, to lie glibly pro and con in the vitiating club-debates, to be schooled in the cult of altruism, to walk softly and talk purringly and self-consciously. while the source of real development along simple, healthy, manlv and womanly ways, lie in obvious neplect ?