The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 2 · February 1914
46printed page
scan 14 of 32
Facsimile · scan 14 of 32
Scan of p. 46
Text · transcribed from the scan

knows how to carry it out in practical life. For the future, we wish that Mr. Dyk should extend our share in the management.

“As for ourselves, it is necessary that every one of our comrades should understand that he has to subordinate his individual foibles, his personal idiosyncrasies, to the furtherance of the cause, for the benefit of a newly devolping community united by happiness and harmony. We understand that we need leadership, but we should like to express the wish that Mr. Dyk should be an educator ratlıer than an administrator. \Ve are therefore in favor of Palestine laborers being represented on the Council of the Settlement, but they must have no right to influence our inner organization in any way: they shall only have the rights and duties of all other members of the Councıl.

"A question that is seriously occupying us is the wage question. We members of the Co-operative Settlement are of opinion that the difference of wage is justified not only by the specific conditions of our problem but also by practice itself. We shall always be in favor of work receiving its due reward. Although we think that the wage is at present too high because the farm does not yield a profit, we also realize that in practice it cannot be otherwise. As for the minimum wage we should like Dr. Oppenheimer to explain how this should be fixed for Jewish laborers in Palestine.

"As regards the Arab question we members of the Co-operative Settlement are of opinion that within the Settlement only such things should be done as can be carried out by Jews. We are opposed to Arab laborers being employed at all among us: we are opposed to this even on economic grounds, as Mr. Dyk asserts, because among us remuneration is given according to work done. Among many of us this standpoint is purely a matter of sentiment, and the opponents of this standpoint must reckon with it and not hurt our feelings.

"In conclusion we beg Dr. Oppenheimer to have his work 'Die Sied-

lungsgenossenschaft' (The Co-operative Settlement) translated into Hebrew."

Dr. Oppenheimer's description of the site and equipments of Merchavia follows:

“Eastwards from the ancient Arab village, in which the laborers and colonists must still crowd together, there lies upon another hill beyond a little valley, in imposing grandeur, a veritable delight to the eves, the estate of Merchavia. It will one day comprise an immense group of buildings, a hun(red metres square, with a yard a hectare ın arca. But for the present the south side is entirely unoccupied, and of the east front more than half, whilst the north and west sides also are not fully erected yet. To the north lies the pride of the estate, tlıe spaciousliy planned stable and granary, all but a third complete. It contains accommodations for the team-beasts and for half of the herd of milk-cattle that will be maintained:; an annex for the other half is in the course of construction. On the side facing the sun there is a broad patlı in front of the ground floor opening towards the yard through several Arabic arches. it prevents the southern sun from warming the building itself. The windows ‚look out to the north, so that a healthy temperature will prevail even in the heat of summer. Above the stable, beneath the flat Oriental roof, are hay-lofts: at present they are crammed with laborers’ families who could not find any more room on the overcrowded hill. It is high time that the colonists’ village, which is being built on the plateau, should be extended another gun-shot further eastwards and that the estate laborers’ houses should at last be finished, in order to put an end to this unsanitary overcrowding of dwelling-rooms. For the present there are onlv two laborers’ houses on the estate but what are two lahorers’ houses in relation to the en orımous need?* One of these is used hr the administration for consultinzeanrms. office. and official residence

*Two more houses have since been voted by the Jewish National Fund and will soon be built.