MERCHAVIA: FIRST CO-OPERATIVE COLONY IN PALESTINE
In March, 1912, Dr. I’ranz Oppenheimer visited Palestine and reported on the progress of Merchavia, the first Jewish co-operative settlement attempted under his guidance. This progress can best be judged by the following report which the members of the co-operative settlement submitted to him:
“It is not easy to inform those interested in Dr. Oppenheimer's Co-operative Settlement idea whether the experiment in Merchavia will attain an early success. Many and various obstacles stood in the wav of this magnificent project at the beginning. One of the most important was that the idea of an Oppenheimer Co-operative Settlement was not popular in Palestine. Another thing was that at the time when the experiment was about to be talken in hand the form of lahor groups was vigorously propagated in the country, and a few such groups had alrcady been at work. The laborers of Palestine preceived in the system of groups the sole possibility of furthering colonization by the Jewish proletariat. "They assumed that through the feeling of responsibility which would be aroused in them by entrusting a national possession to their own management, the self-interest of tlre laborer would be more strengthened than by the undertakines in which an administrator had to bear the responsibility. A further— psvchologiecal—reason was. they wished to be freed from the pressure of the administrator.
"When Mr. Dyk arrived in Palestine as leader of the Co-operative Settlement and undertook its practical realization he found no response or sympathy for the Oppenheimer idea owing to its unpopularity and owing to the tendency for the formation of groups. Moreover, the laborers combatted the principle of remuneration according to production, as contained in the co-operative scheme, and feared that if the management were replaced in the hands
of a leader they would be hampered in their freedom of will as in all administered undertakings, which must destroy all co-operation at the very outset.
"We here know now that the laborers thought and acted wrongly. In the first place they overrated their own ability, as they lack technical and organizing qualifications. Secondly, they had a wrong notion about the method of management in the Oppenheimer Co-operative Settlement. But the most serious error made by the laborers was in overlooking the significance of a possible failure, as this would not only involve the fate of an important question of Palestinian colonization and but also inflict an immeasurable loss upon upward-striving humanity.
"Thus Mr. Dyk found no laborers. He began the undertaking and accepted every workman who offered himself to carry out the initial preparations. (It may be marked in parenthesis that Mr. Dyk was assisted only by his three pupils and a Palestinian laborer.) The laborers who accepted employment on the estate of the Co-operative Settlement did so for the following reasons: first, mostly on account of the remuneration; secondly, as a matter of accident; and thirdly, many people said, 'Perhaps something will turn out of it that can make me enthusiastic for the thing.'
"In the course of the first farming year a number of the laborers became convinced adherents of the scheme, and when Mr. Dyk chose the first ten members these were already conscious of the important task and co-opted only those whom they credited with a marked interest in the Settlement idea and in whom they foresaw faithful fellow-workers and comrades. Up to the present day we have increased to 16 members, who intend with all our strength to realize the idea of the Co-operative Settlement. Our aim is to co-opt all other members from the unattached laborers of