The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 1 · January 1914
6printed page
scan 8 of 34
6
THE MACCABÆAN

with discretion to make propaganda for direct Zionist work among those who still lack faith in Zionism but are willing to go in for Hebraic culture.

The Jewish Chautauqua

The twenty-fifth anniversary of the Jewish Chautauqua Assembly was celebrated in Philadelphia, where it had its birth, last month, and many congratulations were received by Dr. Henry Berkowitz, its founder. The Assembly deserves to be congratulated by all Jews interested in the spread of Jewish education. During its first years, the organization depended a great deal upon publicity and made boast of accomplishing a great deal when it was doing practically very little. In recent years, however, modesty has come in, and the better the work the assembly is doing, the less is being said about it by its leaders. Once it used to be a summer assembly at a summer resort, with all its attendant banalities and apologetics. Now, with a correspondence school, with publications, with field work by capable secretaries, with many assemblies held in winter as well as in summer, the Jewish Chautauqua has become a real force in Jewish life.

Jacob H. Schiff on Zionism

Jacob H. Schiff has again delivered his views on Zionisn, but his attitude is more friendly and appreciative. He gives his approval of Palestine work, and has quite a number of words of praise for the movement in general. He confessed that he is not a Zionist, but qualified it by saying: “If the term is used to designate the Jew as a national separatist among the nations of the world, or even if it intends to form him into a people indepednent of the faith of his ancestors.” This would be conclusive especially with regard to the first qualilication. But in giving his ideas as to what is nationality Mr. Schiff shows a mental confusion. He errs in confounding the term nationality, first using it in an ethnic sense, then ina civic or political sense. There is an American nation politicallv speakine. but

ethnically, America is a conglomeration of nations. The Zionists claim that the Jews are an ethnic group, scattered about in different territories, where, in rare instances, one ethnic group is identical with the civic nationality, and in a majority of instances there is no predominant ethnic group. For example, in Austria, under one government, which is politically the Austrian nation, there are a large number of ethnic nationalities. In Russia, there are probably two score nationalities comprising the Russian empire. In America, we have the same condition of affairs. There is probably no pure nation where one ethnic group is identical with the nation as a political entity. Now, in the midst of these nationalities, federated into one government, the Jews are also settled. On the one hand, ethnically, they are a separate nationality; but on the other, politically, they are part and parcel of the nation. In some countries they are admitted as citizens of the first class, in others they are subjected to special legislation which makes of them citizens of the second and third class. Furthermore, being located in territories where there are contending ethnic groups, and being citizens of the second class, suffering a disability which other ethnic groups do not suffer, the Jews are not acting contrary to the interests of the state of which they are part if they engage in establishing their national or ethnic group upon a national territory, where they shall be in the majority, and in a position to maintain their national integrity, which includes their religion, ethics, philosophy, art, traditions, etc.

National Separatists

Approving Jewish work in Palestine, Mr. Schiff must approve of what its consequences will be. To establish a ponderable Jewish population in Palestine means the creation of a Jewish centre, where all that is characteristic of Jewish life will have an opportunity to develop. This means that ultimately an ethnic nationality will be brought to life separated from other ethnic nationalities insofar as that can be done. Palestine will not be settled exclusively by Jews, but there will be other ethnic