the periphery of civilization but on the contrary quite feasible at the center. The result of this pamphlet was to divide Hertzka's followers. The greater number went with Oppenheimer who from that time has never wearied advocating the ideas of his "Co-operative Settlement" for the attainment of Freeland in Germany.
OPPENHEIMER'S THEORY OF CO-OPERATION
To this end he published in 1896 an important volume entitled “The Co-operative Settlement. An Attempt at a Positive Refutation of Communionism by the Solution of the Problem of Co-operation and of the Agricultural Question.” Its leading thought is this: The cause of all social evil in the world lies in the fact that the soil of the planet which in itself would be more than sufficient to supply all men with the neccessary land has been monopolized by the upper classes and kept from the lower classes. This monopoly is the creation of the primitive conquering might that everywhere created the state and the right of private property. If we could succeed in destroying this land monopoly, the class of disengaged laborers would disappear, that is, of property-less proletarians, for every.one would be able to obtain suffhicient land for inderendent farming. Everything that is dıngerous and damnable in modern capitalism would disappear at the same time, and all that is laudible and useful—free competition with its beneficent influence upon individual initiative and the productivity of social labor— would remain. This is Oppenheimer’s liberal Socialism in a nutchell
WHEREIN HE DIFFERS FROM HENRY GEORGE
Thus far Oppenheimer occupies exactly the same position as Henry George whom he recognizes as his greatest master and as one of the highest benefactors of humanity. He too is in a certain sense a "land reformer." However, as a consequence of a somewhat different diagnosis, there follows necessarily a different plan of cure. Henry George, who saw in all private property in land the root of evil, was obliged to aim at the removal of all property in land, and so arrived at his proposition of taxing out of existence all land rent. Oppenheimer, who, on the con-
trary, recognized that the fault lies not in private property in land as such, but only in the restriction upon the acquisition of land, directs his attacks only against that form of land ownership in which deprivation of land plays a part, viz., land ownership on a large scale. Remove this, he says, and private property retains all its advantages and loses all its harmful effects.
Ilence he recommends every means of “internal colonization,” that is, of transforming the great cstates into independent peasant possessions by buying out the great landed proprietors. Ahove all, he vecommends as the most effective means of internal colonization seli-help of the Iower classes by way of co-operative combinations and co-operative associations of agricultural producers to the highest form of association, viz.. to the “co-operative settlement.”
By a very happy analysis of the concept of competition he has demonstrated indisputably that the failure of co-operative societies of the industrial productive type does not imply, as had been always assumed, the same fate for agricultural co-operative societies. The two forms are from a social-psychological point of view poles asunder. While economic analysis proves that co-operative societies of the industrial type must always go down, the opposite is true of agricultural societies. Experience shows that the theory is correct. All attempts at co-operative organizations of agricultural workers that have been thus far started have succeeded in proportion as they approached the theoretical ideal.
Hıs LITERARY ACTIVITY
These ideas have been developed and defended hy Oppenheimer against all attacks «during eighteen years of labor. This tireless scholar has issued in uninterrupted sequence of work after work and every one of these raised his reputation. In 1808 appeared a large volume entitled “Land Ownership on a Large Scale, and the Social Question, an Attempt at Laying a New Foundation for Social Science” There followed in 1900, 1903 and 1908 three critical analyses of the most important opposing economic doctrines—the Malthustan law of population, Marx’s law of capitalistic accumulation. and Ricardo’s Law of
